Sign in

b-money and Bit Gold

1998

Wei Dai's b-money and Nick Szabo's Bit Gold sketch digital money built from proof of work and cryptography. Neither launches, but the Bitcoin whitepaper cites b-money.

The story

In 1998 two cryptography enthusiasts, Wei Dai and Nick Szabo, separately sketched designs for digital money that would work without a bank or government. Dai's b-money, posted to the cypherpunks mailing list in November 1998, described a system in which every participant kept a record of who owned what, new money was created by those who solved computational puzzles, and payments were announced to everyone. Szabo's Bit Gold, described around the same time and written up publicly in 2005, had participants solve puzzles whose answers were chained together with timestamps, producing a unique, hard-to-forge digital item.

Both built on Adam Back's Hashcash, which showed computing effort could serve as proof, and on the cypherpunk goal of private, uncensorable money, an effort that went back to David Chaum's digital cash of the 1980s. Each had weaknesses: b-money's way of agreeing on records was vague, and Bit Gold relied on a registry that needed trust. Neither was built. But when Satoshi Nakamoto released the Bitcoin whitepaper in 2008, it cited b-money, and Bitcoin's design combined elements of both, with a chain of puzzle solutions agreed through majority computing power. Dai and Szabo have both denied being Satoshi, and the identity remains unknown.

Why it mattered

  • Bitcoin's design drew on these proposals, combining proof of work with a shared record.
  • Their ideas showed that digital scarcity could be created from computing cost, not from a trusted issuer.
  • Szabo's later work on smart contracts helped shape the ideas behind Ethereum.
  • They are cited by historians of cryptocurrency as evidence that Bitcoin had a long intellectual history.

Sources

  1. b-money Wei Dai
  2. Bit Gold Nick Szabo (Nakamoto Institute)
  3. Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System Satoshi Nakamoto

Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

BookNathaniel Popper
Digital Gold
Search Open Library
VideoSearch YouTube
Wei Dai b-money Nick Szabo Bit Gold
Search YouTube