Sign in

The Vault

Case files on contested history: UFOs, government secrets, lost civilizations and the stories people still argue about. Every file opens with what the record shows, then lays out each serious alternative on the same evidence scale.

Drawers 20

  1. IUFOs and UAP16
  2. IIGovernment secrets, exposed and alleged45
  3. IIIDocumented abuses of power38
  4. IVVanished, unsolved and unexplained24
  5. VAssassinations and attacks21
  6. VIMoney, power and legend12
  7. VIIWar, politics and the arguments over them29
  8. VIIIDisasters and the questions they left17
  9. IXAncient stones8
  10. XAncient mysteries9
  11. XIOrigins and identities13
  12. XIITexts, authors and works20
  13. XIIIArtifacts that keep people arguing7
  14. XIVSigns in the sky10
  15. XVDeep time debates35
  16. XVIScience and medicine under dispute13
  17. XVIICollapses and catastrophes5
  18. XVIIIPopes, saints and miracles9
  19. XIXSport and spectacle6
  20. XXModern disputes2

Declassified archives

Drawer I

UFOs and UAP

From the first flying saucer headlines to the Pentagon's 2024 report: what was seen, what was investigated, and what the files say.

  1. 1947Kenneth Arnold sightingOn 24 June 1947 Kenneth Arnold, an experienced private pilot, reported nine bright objects flying fast in a chain near Mount Rainier. His account…
  2. 1947Roswell incidentIn 1947 debris was recovered on a ranch near Roswell, New Mexico.
  3. 1952Washington, D.C. UFO sightingsOn two weekends in July 1952 radar operators at Washington National Airport and Andrews Air Force Base tracked unidentified targets over the capital…
  4. 1952Project Blue BookFrom 1952 to 1969 the Air Force's Project Blue Book logged 12,618 UFO reports, explained most as conventional objects, natural phenomena or hoaxes,…
  5. 1953Robertson PanelIn January 1953 a CIA-convened panel of scientists chaired by H. P. Robertson reviewed Air Force UFO evidence, found no threat to national security…
  6. 1955Area 51Area 51 is a real Air Force test site used for secret aircraft such as the U-2, the A-12 and early stealth planes. CIA documents released in 2013…
  7. 1969Condon ReportThe University of Colorado UFO study directed by physicist Edward Condon, released in January 1969, concluded that two decades of UFO study had…
  8. 1980Rendlesham Forest incidentOver two nights in December 1980 U.S. Air Force personnel near RAF Woodbridge in Suffolk reported unexplained lights in Rendlesham Forest.
  9. 1997Phoenix LightsThere were two events: a V-shaped pattern of lights moving across the state around 8:30 p.m., and stationary lights near Phoenix around 10 p.m. The…
  10. 2004USS Nimitz "Tic Tac" encounterExperienced pilots and radar operators reported an object they could not identify. The Navy has never publicly explained it, and the full radar data…
  11. 2017Pentagon UFO program revealedFrom 2008 to 2012 the Defense Intelligence Agency ran a program of about 22 million dollars, contracted mostly to Robert Bigelow's company and later…
  12. 2020Pentagon releases Navy UAP videosIn April 2020 the Defense Department officially released three Navy infrared videos from 2004 and 2015, known as FLIR1, Gimbal and GoFast, which had…
  13. 2021U.S. intelligence UAP assessmentIn June 2021 the Office of the Director of National Intelligence reported on 144 military UAP reports from 2004 to 2021. It explained one with high…
  14. 2023David Grusch testifies to CongressGrusch testified under oath that other officials told him about crash-retrieval programs. He has said he did not see craft himself. The Defense…
  15. 2024AARO Historical Record ReportIn March 2024 the Pentagon's All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office reported that its review of records from 1945 to 2023 found no verifiable evidence…
  16. 1984Majestic 12 documentsThe FBI's files and the Air Force's 1988 judgment that the documents were bogus, along with forensic analysis of their format, point to forgery. No…
Drawer II

Government secrets, exposed and alleged

Some of these were proven by the government's own documents. Others remain claims.

  1. 1945Operation PaperclipAfter World War II the U.S. brought more than 1,500 German scientists and technicians to America under Project Paperclip.
  2. 1953Iran coup (Operation Ajax)The CIA and British intelligence planned and funded the August 1953 coup, as declassified CIA histories confirm, working with Iranian royalists,…
  3. 1954Guatemala coupThe CIA organized, armed and directed the 1954 operation, codenamed PBSuccess, that forced Árbenz to resign.
  4. 1953MKUltraFrom 1953 to 1973 the CIA ran secret experiments on mind control, including dosing people with LSD, some without consent.
  5. 1963Project MockingbirdProject Mockingbird was a 1963 CIA wiretap of two syndicated columnists, disclosed in the agency's Family Jewels documents.
  6. 1956COINTELPROFBI files released after the 1971 Media, Pennsylvania burglary and the Church Committee's 1976 report document COINTELPRO's covert operations…
  7. 1962Operation NorthwoodsIn 1962 the Joint Chiefs proposed staging fake attacks to justify an invasion of Cuba.
  8. 1964Gulf of Tonkin incidentCongress authorized war after reported North Vietnamese attacks on U.S. destroyers in August 1964.
  9. 1972Stargate remote-viewing programFrom 1972 to 1995 U.S. intelligence agencies funded research and operations using psychic remote viewing, later known as Stargate.
  10. 1975Church CommitteeThe Church Committee's published reports documented decades of abuses by the CIA, FBI, NSA and IRS and led to lasting reforms. Claims that it…
  11. 1975Operation CondorSouth American dictatorships ran a joint program to track and kill opponents abroad, documented by Paraguay's 1992 'Archives of Terror' and later…
  12. 1986Iran-Contra affairReagan administration officials secretly sold arms to Iran and diverted proceeds to Nicaraguan Contra rebels despite a congressional ban.
  13. 1990Operation Gladio revealedSecret stay-behind networks, coordinated with NATO and the CIA, existed in many Western European countries during the Cold War.
  14. 1933Reichstag fireDutch communist Marinus van der Lubbe was caught at the scene and executed; the Nazis used the fire to suspend civil liberties.
  15. 1941Pearl HarborJapan's surprise attack on 7 December 1941 killed about 2,400 Americans.
  16. 1972WatergateA burglary at Democratic headquarters and the White House cover-up led to Nixon's resignation.
  17. 2003Iraq WarThe U.S. and allies invaded Iraq in 2003, citing weapons of mass destruction.
  18. 2013Snowden revelationsIn 2013 Edward Snowden leaked documents on U.S. and allied surveillance.
  19. 1946Operation HighjumpNavy records show Highjump was a large training, mapping and sovereignty expedition that ended early because of the approaching Antarctic winter.…
  20. 1961Operation MongooseDeclassified planning papers and the Church Committee's 1975 report confirm Mongoose and multiple CIA plots against Castro. How much the Kennedys…
  21. 1943Venona projectNSA's 1995 release of the decrypts and its own histories document Venona in detail. The decrypts confirm large scale Soviet espionage in wartime…
  22. 1971ECHELON surveillance networkThe European Parliament's 2001 inquiry and documents leaked in 2013 confirm a Five Eyes satellite interception system code named ECHELON. Claims…
  23. 1974CIA "Family Jewels" exposedThe CIA released the Family Jewels in 2007, confirming the internal list of questionable activities that Hersh reported in 1974. The document is the…
  24. 1996Dark Alliance and the Contra cocaine allegationsCongressional and CIA reviews confirm that some Contra supporters trafficked cocaine and that the CIA kept working with people it knew were…
  25. 1980October Surprise allegationsOfficial inquiries in 1992 and 1993 found no credible evidence of a deal between the Reagan campaign and Iran. A 2023 eyewitness account of a…
  26. 1992The Montauk Project legendCamp Hero was a real Cold War radar station that closed in 1981. The claims of mind control and time travel come from a 1992 book and its sequels,…
  27. 1960U-2 incidentCIA histories and State Department records confirm the overflight program and the false cover story. Theories about why Powers was shot down, and…
  28. 1962Project 112 and SHADPentagon fact sheets released in 2002 and Senate hearings confirm that Project 112 and SHAD exposed service members to chemical and biological…
  29. 1974Project AzorianThe CIA declassified its history of Project Azorian in 2010, confirming the operation, the Hughes cover story and the partial recovery. What the…
  30. 1969Secret bombing of CambodiaAir Force records and 1973 Senate testimony confirm the secret bombing and the falsified records. Its military value and its role in Cambodia's…
  31. 1958Project A119Leonard Reiffel's 2000 disclosure and the surviving study report confirm that the Air Force examined a nuclear explosion on the Moon. No plan to…
  32. 1971Pentagon PapersThe full Pentagon Papers, released by the National Archives in 2011, confirm that the secret Defense Department history documented decisions on…
  33. 1973Coup in ChileDeclassified U.S. records and the CIA's 2000 Hinchey Report confirm a long covert campaign against Salvador Allende. Whether the United States…
  34. 1917Zimmermann TelegramGerman foreign secretary Arthur Zimmermann secretly proposed a German-Mexican alliance against the United States in January 1917. British…
  35. 1924Zinoviev letterA letter attributed to Comintern head Grigory Zinoviev was published four days before Britain's 1924 election, damaging the Labour government. An…
  36. 1942Anthrax tests on Gruinard Island and Operation VegetarianBritish scientists tested anthrax bombs on Gruinard Island in 1942 and 1943 and prepared millions of anthrax cattle cakes for possible retaliation…
  37. 1943Operation MincemeatBritish intelligence planted fake invasion plans on a corpse off Spain in April 1943, and German records and intercepts show Hitler's command…
  38. 1944Operation Fortitude and the Double Cross systemOperation Fortitude used double agents, fake radio traffic and a fictional army group to convince Germany the main 1944 invasion would land at…
  39. 1951Cambridge Five spy ring exposedFive Cambridge-educated Britons recruited by Soviet intelligence in the 1930s spied from inside the Foreign Office, MI6, MI5 and wartime…
  40. 1960Mossad captures Adolf EichmannIsraeli agents abducted Adolf Eichmann in Buenos Aires in May 1960 and flew him to Israel, where he was tried and executed. The operation is fully…
  41. 1963Profumo affairWar minister John Profumo lied to Parliament about an affair with Christine Keeler, who also knew a Soviet intelligence officer, and resigned in…
  42. 1974Biopreparat, the secret Soviet bioweapons programThe Soviet Union ran a large secret offensive biological weapons program, much of it hidden inside the civilian Biopreparat agency, in breach of the…
  43. 1979Vela incidentA U.S. Vela satellite recorded a double flash typical of a nuclear explosion over the South Atlantic on September 22, 1979. A White House panel…
  44. 1986Vanunu exposes Israel's nuclear weaponsFormer Dimona technician Mordechai Vanunu gave The Sunday Times evidence in 1986 that Israel had a large nuclear arsenal, and Mossad abducted him…
  45. 1992Mitrokhin Archive reaches BritainKGB archivist Vasili Mitrokhin secretly copied foreign intelligence files for twelve years and defected to Britain in 1992. His notes, published…
Drawer III

Documented abuses of power

Crimes and catastrophes the record establishes, kept apart from the speculative files. What remains argued over here is mostly scale, intent and responsibility, not whether they happened.

  1. 1941The HolocaustAbout six million Jews were murdered, a total built from Nazi Germany's own records and from population counts before and after the war. Early…
  2. 1940Katyn massacreThe NKVD executed the prisoners on Stalin's orders in spring 1940; the USSR admitted this in 1990 and released the execution order in 1992.
  3. 1932Tuskegee syphilis study beginsFrom 1932 to 1972, U.S. health officials studied untreated syphilis in hundreds of Black men without informed consent, even after penicillin became…
  4. 1972Tuskegee study exposedU.S. Public Health Service researchers observed untreated syphilis in about 400 Black men from 1932 to 1972, withholding treatment and informed…
  5. 1965Indonesian mass killings of 1965-66The Indonesian army and allied civilian groups killed hundreds of thousands of suspected communists in 1965-66 after the 30 September Movement's…
  6. 1770Bengal famine of 1770Drought caused crop failure in Bengal in 1769 and 1770; the scale of deaths and the East India Company's share of blame are debated.
  7. 1943Bengal famine of 1943About three million people died; most historians agree the famine was driven by war, inflation and policy failure rather than a large drop in food…
  8. 1930Kazakh famineStalin's collectivization and forced settlement of nomadic Kazakhs caused a famine in 1930-33 that killed about 1.5 million people, but whether it…
  9. 1930The Gulag labor camp systemThe Soviet camp system held millions in forced labor from 1930 to the 1950s. Historians agree on its scale from archives but still differ on total…
  10. 1937Stalin's Great TerrorThe Great Terror was a campaign directed by Stalin that killed about 680,000 people by execution in 1937 and 1938. Historians debate its causes and…
  11. 1956Khrushchev's Secret SpeechKhrushchev's speech was a real and consequential denunciation of Stalin, but a limited one. Historians debate his motives and its limits.
  12. 1885Congo Free State atrocitiesLeopold II's regime used systematic coercion and violence to extract rubber, causing a large population loss, but the scale cannot be measured…
  13. 1937Nanjing MassacreJapanese forces killed large numbers of Chinese prisoners and civilians in and around Nanjing in December 1937 and January 1938, with widespread…
  14. 2003Darfur genocideSudanese forces and Janjaweed militias committed mass killings and expulsions of non-Arab communities in Darfur; whether this legally constitutes…
  15. 1876Great Famine of 1876-78 in IndiaA severe drought caused crop failure, but British policies on grain, taxation and relief made it far deadlier; how much blame colonial policy…
  16. 1876North China Famine of 1876-79A multi-year drought and a weakened Qing state caused a famine that killed millions; the exact toll is uncertain.
  17. 1834Indian indentured labor systemIndenture was a system of contract labor with real elements of coercion and high mortality, and historians disagree on whether it should be called a…
  18. 1952Mau Mau uprising in KenyaMau Mau was a predominantly Kikuyu uprising against land loss and colonial rule, put down with mass detention, executions and documented abuses.
  19. 1955Operation Midnight ClimaxSurviving CIA financial records and testimony at the 1977 Senate MKUltra hearing confirm that the agency funded safehouses where unwitting people…
  20. 1945U.S. human radiation experimentsThe 1995 report of the Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments, based on declassified records, confirms that federal agencies sponsored…
  21. 2002CIA black sites and the torture programThe program is documented by declassified CIA cables, Justice Department memos, Red Cross reports and the 2014 Senate Intelligence Committee study.…
  22. 2004Abu Ghraib prisoner abuseArmy investigations, courts-martial and the photographs themselves establish that detainees were abused at Abu Ghraib in late 2003. The open…
  23. 1967Phoenix ProgramCIA records and Colby's own testimony confirm that Phoenix existed and that tens of thousands were captured or killed. What remains disputed is how…
  24. 1950Projects Bluebird and ArtichokeDeclassified CIA memos document Bluebird and Artichoke, including drug and hypnosis interrogations of unwitting subjects. Documents released in 2026…
  25. 1950Operation Sea-SprayMilitary records released in the 1970s and 1977 Senate testimony confirm the Navy sprayed bacteria over San Francisco in 1950. Whether the spraying…
  26. 2001Stellar Wind warrantless surveillanceInspector general reports released in 2009 and 2015 confirm Stellar Wind's warrantless collection. Its legality and effectiveness remain disputed.
  27. 1945Operation ShamrockThe Church Committee's 1975 to 1976 investigation documented Shamrock in detail. It is one of the clearest cases of mass warrantless surveillance of…
  28. 1967Project MINARETAn NSA history declassified in 2013 and the Church Committee record confirm MINARET and name prominent targets. The program's legality was doubted…
  29. 1967Operation CHAOSThe Rockefeller Commission and Church Committee reports of 1975 and 1976 document CHAOS in detail, and its legal violations are not seriously…
  30. 1964FBI's anonymous letter to Martin Luther King Jr.The Church Committee and the FBI's own files confirm the bureau sent the anonymous letter and tape. Its wording and authorship are documented;…
  31. 1969Killing of Fred HamptonA federal grand jury, the civil lawsuit and the Church Committee record establish that police fired nearly all the shots and that an FBI informant…
  32. 2009Operation Fast and FuriousThe Justice Department inspector general and congressional investigators documented the operation's failures. A competing claim that it was designed…
  33. 1953Project SunshineAEC records reviewed by the 1995 presidential advisory committee and later inquiries abroad confirm Project Sunshine collected human remains,…
  34. 1946Guatemala syphilis experimentsPublic Health Service records and the 2011 presidential bioethics commission establish that U.S. researchers deliberately infected Guatemalans…
  35. 1955Edgewood Arsenal human experimentsDefense Department reports and VA records confirm the Edgewood testing on about 6,700 service members. Its long term health effects are still debated.
  36. 1968My Lai massacreThe Peers Commission and court-martial records establish the massacre and the Army's cover up. Debate continues over the death toll and over how far…
  37. 1936Unit 731 and Japan's germ warfare programUnit 731 ran human experiments and germ warfare attacks in China from 1936 to 1945, and its leaders were granted immunity by U.S. authorities in…
  38. 1894Dreyfus AffairCaptain Alfred Dreyfus, a Jewish French army officer, was convicted of treason in 1894 on the basis of a document actually written by Major…
Drawer IV

Vanished, unsolved and unexplained

Disappearances, strange deaths and puzzles that investigators still argue over.

  1. 1483Princes in the Tower vanishEdward V and Richard of York were last seen in the Tower of London in 1483 and were never seen alive again.
  2. 1587Lost Colony of RoanokeThe 1587 English colony on Roanoke Island had vanished by 1590, leaving the word CROATOAN carved on a post.
  3. 1821Death of NapoleonNapoleon died on Saint Helena in May 1821, and his autopsy found a large stomach ulcer with signs of cancer.
  4. 1828Kaspar Hauser appears in NurembergKaspar Hauser appeared in Nuremberg in 1828 claiming a lifetime of captivity and died of a stab wound in 1833.
  5. 1908Tunguska eventOn 30 June 1908 a cosmic body exploded several kilometers above Siberia and flattened about 2,000 square kilometers of forest.
  6. 1918Execution of the RomanovsTsar Nicholas II, his wife and their five children were shot by Bolsheviks in Yekaterinburg in July 1918.
  7. 1937Amelia Earhart disappearsAmelia Earhart and Fred Noonan disappeared on 2 July 1937 while trying to reach Howland Island in the Pacific.
  8. 1945Flight 19 and the Bermuda TriangleOn 5 December 1945 five Navy Avenger bombers on a training flight got lost off Florida, and a PBM Mariner sent to search for them was also lost.
  9. 1956Philadelphia Experiment story beginsClaims that the Navy made the destroyer escort USS Eldridge invisible or teleported it in 1943 first surfaced in letters to Morris Jessup in 1956.
  10. 1959Dyatlov Pass incidentIn February 1959 nine Soviet hikers died after cutting their way out of their tent on Kholat Syakhl in the northern Urals.
  11. 1971D. B. Cooper hijackingOn 24 November 1971 a man called Dan Cooper hijacked a Northwest Orient jet, took a $200,000 ransom and parachuted out over Washington State.
  12. 1983Korean Air Lines Flight 007 shot downThe airliner drifted off course because of a crew navigation error, and Soviet air defenses shot it down believing it was a spy plane.
  13. 1988Lockerbie bombingLibyan intelligence officer Abdelbaset al-Megrahi was convicted in 2001 by a Scottish court sitting in the Netherlands, and Libya accepted…
  14. 1997Death of Princess DianaFrench and British investigations and a 2008 London inquest found the crash was caused by the grossly negligent driving of Henri Paul, who had been…
  15. 2000Kursk submarine disasterRussian investigators found that leaking high-test peroxide fuel in a practice torpedo exploded and set off other warheads.
  16. 2019Jeffrey Epstein dies in federal custodyNew York City's medical examiner ruled suicide by hanging; a 2023 Justice Department inspector general report found serious negligence by jail staff…
  17. 2014Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 vanishesSatellite data and debris show the plane flew for hours after vanishing from radar and ended in the southern Indian Ocean; searches through 2026…
  18. 2016Havana syndrome reportedUS intelligence assessed in 2023, and again in 2025, that a foreign adversary very likely did not cause the incidents, while accepting that…
  19. 2022Nord Stream pipelines sabotagedInvestigators agree the pipelines were deliberately blown up. Sweden and Denmark closed their probes in February 2024 without naming anyone; German…
  20. 1888Jack the Ripper murdersAn unidentified killer murdered at least five women in Whitechapel, London, in 1888, and police never charged anyone. Officials privately suspected…
  21. 1872Mary Celeste found abandonedThe Mary Celeste was found sailing without its crew in December 1872, seaworthy and with its cargo largely intact, and the ten people aboard were…
  22. 1945Amber Room vanishesGerman troops looted the Amber Room from near Leningrad in 1941 and displayed it in Konigsberg, where it was last seen packed in crates near the end…
  23. 1948Tamam Shud case (the Somerton Man)An unidentified man was found dead on Somerton Beach, Adelaide, in December 1948, carrying a scrap from the Rubaiyat linked to a book with an…
  24. 1965Disappearance of Mehdi Ben BarkaMehdi Ben Barka was abducted in Paris on October 29, 1965 by French police officers acting with Moroccan officials, and his body has never been…
Drawer V

Assassinations and attacks

Who did it, who knew, and what the investigations found.

  1. 1901McKinley assassinatedLeon Czolgosz, a self-described anarchist, shot McKinley on 6 September 1901 and was tried, convicted and executed within weeks.
  2. 1935Huey Long assassinatedThe accepted account is that Dr. Carl Weiss shot Long in a capitol corridor on 8 September 1935 and was immediately killed by Long's bodyguards.
  3. 1948Gandhi assassinatedGodse fired the shots on 30 January 1948; he and Narayan Apte were hanged in 1949 after a trial that convicted several co-conspirators.
  4. 1961Patrice Lumumba assassinatedKatangan authorities executed Lumumba on 17 January 1961 with Belgian officers present; a Belgian parliamentary inquiry found that Belgium bore…
  5. 1961Dag Hammarskjöld dies in plane crashThe cause is unresolved: early inquiries blamed pilot error or found no cause, and the UN investigation led by Mohamed Chande Othman finds it…
  6. 1963JFK assassinatedPresident Kennedy was shot in Dallas on 22 November 1963. Lee Harvey Oswald was arrested and then killed two days later.
  7. 1965Malcolm X assassinatedMembers of the Nation of Islam carried out the killing on 21 February 1965; in 2021 two of the three men convicted were exonerated after a review…
  8. 1968Martin Luther King Jr. assassinatedJames Earl Ray pleaded guilty in 1969 and recanted days later. A 1999 civil jury in Memphis (King v. Jowers) found that King was the victim of a…
  9. 1968Robert F. Kennedy assassinatedSirhan Sirhan shot Kennedy in a hotel pantry on 5 June 1968 and was convicted of first-degree murder in 1969.
  10. 1986Olof Palme assassinatedNo one was ever finally convicted; in 2020 prosecutors closed the case by naming a deceased suspect, Stig Engström, who could no longer be charged.
  11. 2001September 11 attacksNineteen al-Qaeda hijackers attacked the U.S., killing nearly 3,000 people.
  12. 1972Operation Wrath of GodAfter the Munich massacre, Israel ran a covert campaign from 1972 to 1979 that killed Palestinians it linked to Black September, including an…
  13. 1978Georgi Markov umbrella assassinationBulgarian dissident Georgi Markov was poisoned with a ricin pellet in London in September 1978 and died four days later. Former KGB officers have…
  14. 1978Kidnapping and murder of Aldo MoroThe Red Brigades kidnapped Aldo Moro in Rome on March 16, 1978 and murdered him after 55 days; members were convicted. Parliamentary commissions…
  15. 1985Sinking of the Rainbow WarriorFrench DGSE agents bombed and sank the Greenpeace ship Rainbow Warrior in Auckland on July 10, 1985, killing Fernando Pereira. France denied it…
  16. 1999Russian apartment bombingsBombs destroyed four apartment blocks in Russia in September 1999, killing about 300 people, and the government blamed militants from the North…
  17. 2006Poisoning of Alexander LitvinenkoAlexander Litvinenko was poisoned with polonium-210 in London on November 1, 2006 and died on November 23. A British public inquiry and the European…
  18. 2014MH17 shot down over UkraineMH17 was shot down over eastern Ukraine on July 17, 2014 by a Buk missile, killing 298 people. Investigators traced the launcher to Russia's 53rd…
  19. 2018Salisbury Novichok poisoningSergei and Yulia Skripal were poisoned with Novichok in Salisbury on March 4, 2018; they survived, but Dawn Sturgess died after handling the…
  20. 2018Murder of Jamal KhashoggiSaudi agents killed journalist Jamal Khashoggi inside the Saudi consulate in Istanbul on October 2, 2018. Saudi Arabia admitted the killing and…
  21. 2020Poisoning of Alexei NavalnyAlexei Navalny was poisoned with a Novichok nerve agent in August 2020, as confirmed by several laboratories and the OPCW, and journalists…
Drawer VI

Money, power and legend

Stories about money and influence where the documented record and the popular version part ways.

  1. 1343Bardi and Peruzzi banks failThe Peruzzi and Bardi companies failed in the 1340s during a wider Florentine banking crisis.
  2. 1815Nathan Rothschild and the Waterloo bond storyNathan Rothschild did help finance Britain's war and did get early private news of Waterloo, but the story that he made a vast fortune by trading on…
  3. 1500Spanish Golden Age (Siglo de Oro)Did the 1492 expulsion cause Spain's Golden Age? No mainstream historian argues that it did. The flowering is traced to empire, humanism, printing…
  4. 1922Teapot Dome scandalFall took roughly $400,000 from oilmen Harry Sinclair and Edward Doheny while leasing them naval reserves, and was convicted of accepting a bribe in…
  5. 1974Petrodollar recyclingIn 1974 the U.S. and Saudi Arabia set up a joint economic commission and Saudi Arabia began investing oil surpluses in U.S. Treasuries; oil was…
  6. 2001Enron collapsesEnron executives used accounting tricks and hidden partnerships to inflate earnings and hide debt; a federal task force won 22 convictions,…
  7. 2002WorldCom fraudWorldCom overstated its income by roughly $11 billion between 1999 and 2002; its CFO pleaded guilty and CEO Bernard Ebbers was convicted in 2005.
  8. 2008Madoff Ponzi scheme exposedMadoff ran the largest known Ponzi scheme; he pleaded guilty in 2009, was sentenced to 150 years and died in prison in 2021.
  9. 2012LIBOR rigging exposedTraders at many banks pushed rate submissions to benefit their positions, and banks lowballed rates during the 2008 crisis; regulators fined banks…
  10. 2015Theranos exposedTheranos's device could run only a limited set of tests and was less reliable than claimed; founder Elizabeth Holmes was convicted in 2022 of…
  11. 2020Wirecard collapsesThe €1.9 billion never existed; Wirecard had inflated much of its Asian business, while Germany's regulator had pursued critics instead of the…
  12. 1982Banco Ambrosiano collapse and the death of Roberto CalviRoberto Calvi, chairman of the collapsing Banco Ambrosiano, was found hanged under Blackfriars Bridge in June 1982. Italian investigators and later…
Drawer VII

War, politics and the arguments over them

Causes, blame and turning points that historians still weigh differently.

  1. 1772Partitions of PolandThe Commonwealth was divided by Russia, Prussia and Austria in 1772, 1793 and 1795. Historians still argue how much Polish internal weakness, rather…
  2. 1389Battle of KosovoThe Ottomans and a Serb-led coalition fought on Kosovo Polje on June 15, 1389, and both leaders died. Medieval accounts disagree on the outcome, and…
  3. 1871Paris CommuneThe Paris Commune was a radical government that ruled the city for 72 days in 1871 and was crushed by the national army, with thousands killed. Its…
  4. 1916Battle of the SommeThe Somme cost over a million casualties and gained little ground, but it also wore down the German army. Historians argue about Haig's leadership…
  5. 1940Fall of FranceGermany defeated France in about six weeks in 1940 through a bold armored breakthrough at Sedan and a flawed Allied plan. The reasons have been…
  6. 1916Sykes-Picot AgreementSykes-Picot was a secret wartime plan that was later changed; the actual borders came from the 1919 to 1923 peace settlements and League mandates.
  7. 1917Balfour DeclarationThe letter is authentic and was the basis of the Mandate; historians debate why Britain issued it and what it promised.
  8. 1980Iran-Iraq WarIraq launched the invasion in September 1980; the war ended in stalemate in 1988 with very heavy losses on both sides.
  9. 2023October 7 attack and the Gaza genocideHamas-led militants killed about 1,200 people in Israel on October 7, 2023, and the Gaza war killed over 70,000 by Gaza officials' count; legal and…
  10. 1001Mahmud of Ghazni raids IndiaMahmud's raids on Indian temples are documented in contemporary Persian sources; their motives and later meaning are disputed.
  11. 1060Almoravid EmpireThe Almoravids built a Saharan and Iberian empire in the 11th century; whether they conquered Ghana is still disputed.
  12. 1816Shaka's Zulu kingdom and the MfecaneShaka built a powerful centralized Zulu kingdom and southern Africa saw widespread wars and migrations in the 1810s to 1830s; historians disagree on…
  13. 1967Nigerian Civil War (Biafra)The war and blockade caused a famine that killed hundreds of thousands to over two million people, mostly civilians; whether it amounted to genocide…
  14. 1998Second Congo WarThe Second Congo War caused an enormous humanitarian catastrophe, but estimates of excess deaths differ widely depending on method.
  15. 1886Haymarket affair and May DayA bomb was thrown at police at the May 4, 1886 rally, but the thrower was never identified, and most historians judge that the trial convicted the…
  16. 1979Thatcher, Reagan and the market turnGovernments in Britain and the US did cut taxes, deregulate and privatize from 1979 to 1981, but historians dispute how far this was a coherent…
  17. 1955Japanese economic miracleJapan's rapid growth came from high investment and savings, education, export markets and favorable US policy, but economists disagree on how much…
  18. 1962South Korea's export-led industrializationSouth Korea's rise combined state-directed credit, export discipline, education and US and Japanese capital; scholars disagree about how decisive…
  19. 1962Operation Fishbowl and Starfish PrimeDefense and NASA studies document the Fishbowl tests and the damage the Starfish Prime radiation belt did to satellites. The tests were public at…
  20. 1967Operation PopeyeDeclassified Senate testimony from 1974 and Defense Department records confirm Popeye's cloud seeding over Indochina. Its actual effect on rainfall…
  21. 1979Operation CycloneThe covert aid program is acknowledged and well documented by participants and historians. Disputes center on Brzezinski's later claims about luring…
  22. 1961CIA's Secret War in LaosDeclassified records, congressional hearings and participant histories document the CIA's war in Laos. Its human cost and links to the drug trade…
  23. 1967USS Liberty incidentNavy and Israeli inquiries concluded the attack was a tragic misidentification. Survivors, some former officials and a former Navy inquiry lawyer…
  24. 1961Bay of Pigs invasionCIA internal reviews, its official history released in 2011 and declassified planning papers document how the agency planned and ran the April 1961…
  25. 1939Gleiwitz incidentSS men disguised as Poles staged an attack on the Gleiwitz radio station on August 31, 1939, and Germany used such incidents to justify invading…
  26. 1939Shelling of MainilaThe Soviet Union blamed Finland for shelling Mainila on November 26, 1939, and invaded four days later. Finnish observers at the time and most later…
  27. 1941Rudolf Hess flies to ScotlandRudolf Hess flew solo to Scotland on May 10, 1941 seeking peace talks and was imprisoned until his death in 1987. Officially he acted alone; whether…
  28. 1954Lavon Affair (Operation Susannah)An Israeli military intelligence cell planted firebombs at British and American sites in Egypt in 1954 to discredit the Egyptian government; it was…
  29. 1932Holodomor and the Soviet famine of 1932 to 1933Soviet grain requisitions and collectivization caused a famine in 1932 and 1933 that killed millions in Ukraine and elsewhere. The Soviet state…
Drawer VIII

Disasters and the questions they left

What happened, how many died, and what could have been done.

  1. 1556Shaanxi earthquakeThe earthquake was among the largest in Chinese history and killed several hundred thousand people; the 830,000 figure comes from Ming-era records…
  2. 1923Great Kanto earthquakeThe Great Kanto earthquake killed about 105,000 people; in its aftermath mobs, police and soldiers killed many Koreans, and the number is disputed.
  3. 19311931 China floodsThe 1931 floods were among the deadliest natural disasters ever, but the death toll is highly uncertain and depends on how famine and disease deaths…
  4. 1970Bhola cycloneThe Bhola cyclone killed hundreds of thousands and the poor official response increased the tension that led to Bangladesh's independence in 1971.
  5. 1976Tangshan earthquakeTangshan was one of the deadliest earthquakes in history; the official toll is about 242,000, though the true figure may be higher.
  6. 1984Bhopal gas disasterA leak of methyl isocyanate from a poorly maintained plant with failing safety systems killed thousands in 1984; the exact total deaths and the way…
  7. 1984Ethiopian famine and Live AidDrought triggered the 1983 to 1985 famine, but war and government policy greatly worsened it; the death toll is uncertain.
  8. 165 CEAntonine PlagueA major epidemic, most likely smallpox, struck the Roman Empire from 165 to about 180 CE and killed millions. Its long term impact on Rome is debated.
  9. 1545Cocoliztli epidemics in MexicoCocoliztli epidemics killed millions of Indigenous people in 16th-century Mexico, but the pathogen or pathogens responsible are debated.
  10. 1970Amazon deforestation acceleratesThe Amazon has lost about a fifth of its Brazilian forest; scientists agree on the trend but argue about how close the forest is to a tipping point.
  11. 2024First year above 1.5 C of warming2024 was the first calendar year above 1.5 degrees C relative to 1850 to 1900, but the Paris Agreement limit concerns a long-term average that has…
  12. 1957Kyshtym nuclear disasterA radioactive waste tank exploded at the Mayak plutonium plant on September 29, 1957, contaminating about 20,000 square kilometers. The Soviet Union…
  13. 1979Sverdlovsk anthrax leakAn outbreak of inhalation anthrax in Sverdlovsk in April 1979 killed at least 64 people. Soviet officials blamed contaminated meat, but Yeltsin…
  14. 1986Chernobyl disasterReactor 4 at Chernobyl exploded on April 26, 1986, in the worst nuclear accident in history. Soviet authorities said nothing publicly until Sweden…
  15. 1898USS Maine explodes in HavanaThe cause has never been settled: Navy inquiries in 1898 and 1911 blamed a mine, while a 1976 study led by Admiral Rickover pointed to a fire in a…
  16. 1915Lusitania sunkThe U-boat U-20 torpedoed the liner without warning on 7 May 1915; a second explosion moments later helped sink her in about 18 minutes.
  17. 1937Hindenburg disasterAmerican and German inquiries concluded that leaking hydrogen was ignited, most likely by a static or electrical spark as the ship landed in stormy…
Drawer IX

Ancient stones

Monuments whose age or builders are argued over.

  1. 900 CEChichen ItzaChichen Itza shares striking art and architecture with Tula in central Mexico; the reason for the resemblance is debated.
  2. 2,500 BCEGreat Sphinx of GizaMost Egyptologists date the Sphinx to the reign of Khafre, about 2500 BCE, based on its place in his pyramid complex and quarrying.
  3. 15 BCETemple of Jupiter at BaalbekRoman builders raised the temple platform and its giant trilithon blocks from the late first century BCE into the first century CE, on a site…
  4. 550 CEPumapunku built at TiwanakuThe Tiwanaku culture built Pumapunku from about the sixth century CE, using stone tools, abrasives and careful planning.
  5. 1600Ifugao rice terracesThe Ifugao rice terraces are real and remarkable, but their age is disputed: the popular 2,000-year figure lacks firm archaeological support.
  6. 1431Ayutthaya sacks AngkorAngkor's decline as the Khmer capital was gradual and probably had several causes; the 1431 Ayutthaya attack is a traditional date rather than a…
  7. 1968Bimini Road foundGeologists identify the Bimini Road as natural beachrock that cracked into blocks in place.
  8. 1100Polynesians settle HawaiiPolynesians reached Hawaii late in the settlement of the Pacific, but the exact date depends on which radiocarbon samples are trusted.
Drawer X

Ancient mysteries

Lost civilizations, monuments and machines that keep people arguing.

  1. 10,900 BCEYounger Dryas cold snapA sudden cold snap about 12,900 years ago, most likely caused by meltwater disrupting Atlantic ocean currents.
  2. 9,500 BCEGöbekli TepeBuilt by hunter-gatherers around 9500 BCE, likely as a ritual or feasting center.
  3. 2,560 BCEGreat Pyramid of GizaBuilt around 2560 BCE for the pharaoh Khufu by a large, organized Egyptian workforce.
  4. 3,000 BCEStonehengeA monument built in stages from about 3000 to 1500 BCE, aligned with the solstices and used for ceremonies and burials.
  5. 200 BCENazca LinesThe Nazca people made the lines by removing dark stones to reveal lighter ground, likely for ritual walking and water ceremonies.
  6. 100 BCEAntikythera mechanismA Greek astronomical calculator from about the 2nd to 1st century BCE, found in a shipwreck in 1901.
  7. 387 BCEPlato's AcademyPlato founded the Academy and wrote dialogues that shaped Western philosophy. In two dialogues he describes Atlantis.
  8. 285 BCELibrary of AlexandriaThe Library declined over centuries rather than burning in a single fire.
  9. 1,177 BCELate Bronze Age collapseAround 1177 BCE, many eastern Mediterranean civilizations collapsed within decades.
Drawer XI

Origins and identities

Who did it, who wrote it, and where we came from.

  1. 1000Norse reach North AmericaNorse Vikings reached Newfoundland around 1000; tree rings date wood cut at L'Anse aux Meadows to 1021.
  2. 1297Islam takes root in Southeast AsiaIslam reached Southeast Asia gradually through Indian Ocean trade between the 13th and 16th centuries, with Pasai the earliest firmly dated Muslim…
  3. 1800Afro-Atlantic religions: Vodou, Candomble, SanteriaThese religions formed in the Americas from West and Central African traditions, Catholicism and local conditions of slavery.
  4. 300 kaHomo sapiens appearsModern humans evolved in Africa and spread outward, mixing with Neanderthals and Denisovans along the way.
  5. 200 kaComplex languageLanguage evolved at some point in the human lineage, but when is hard to pin down because speech leaves no fossils.
  6. 23,000 BCEDogs domesticatedDogs descend from Ice Age wolves; they were the first domesticated animal.
  7. 21,000 BCEHumans reach the AmericasPeople crossed from Siberia into the Americas during or before the last Ice Age.
  8. 2,070 BCEXia dynasty (traditional)Ancient Chinese histories describe a Xia dynasty before the Shang, but no Xia writing has been found.
  9. 550 BCEHebrew Bible and monotheismThe Hebrew Bible was compiled from older traditions, mostly between the 7th and 5th centuries BCE.
  10. 1,200 BCETrojan War (legendary)Troy was a real city in Anatolia (Hisarlik), destroyed several times; the Iliad blends memory and myth.
  11. 30 CEJesus of Nazareth crucifiedAlmost all historians agree Jesus was a real Jewish preacher executed by the Romans.
  12. 1600ShakespeareWilliam Shakespeare of Stratford-upon-Avon wrote the plays, likely with collaborators on some.
  13. 2009Satoshi Nakamoto creates BitcoinNobody knows who Satoshi Nakamoto is. Satoshi wrote only online, stopped posting in 2011, and the roughly one million bitcoin attributed to…
Drawer XII

Texts, authors and works

Who wrote it, when, and what it meant.

  1. 500 BCEBook of JobMost scholars date the Book of Job to the Persian period or the late exile, between about 600 and 400 BCE, and see it as a compound work shaped over…
  2. 300 BCEQu Yuan and the Songs of ChuQu Yuan is the traditional author of the Li Sao and was probably a real official of Chu, but how much of the Chuci he wrote is uncertain.
  3. 300 CEPanchatantraThe Panchatantra was composed in Sanskrit in the early centuries CE in India; its original text is lost and its date and author are uncertain.
  4. 1100Song of RolandThe Song of Roland took its present form around 1100, probably by one poet called Turoldus, but its date, author and oral background are all debated.
  5. 1350Romance of the Three KingdomsThe novel was composed in the 14th century, probably by Luo Guanzhong, from older tales and Chen Shou's history, but details of its authorship and…
  6. 1947The Diary of Anne FrankThe diary is a genuine wartime document written by Anne Frank, later edited by her father; the exact identity of the person who betrayed the hiding…
  7. 1592Marlowe's Doctor FaustusDoctor Faustus was written by Christopher Marlowe, probably between 1588 and 1592, but the two printed texts differ and neither is certainly his…
  8. 1623Shakespeare's First FolioThe First Folio's title page and tributes attribute the plays to William Shakespeare of Stratford and the London stage, and documentary evidence…
  9. 1606MacbethMacbeth was probably written in 1606 and the Folio text includes a few passages added by Thomas Middleton, though scholars disagree on the extent.
  10. 1609Shakespeare's SonnetsShakespeare wrote the sonnets, most probably in the 1590s with some later, and the 1609 quarto was printed by Thomas Thorpe. Who the young man, the…
  11. 1400Water MarginWater Margin was composed in the late Yuan or early Ming from earlier outlaw stories, and its authorship is uncertain.
  12. 1592Journey to the WestJourney to the West is a Ming dynasty novel first printed around 1592, drawing on the real pilgrimage of Xuanzang, but its author is not certain.
  13. 1,400 BCEHurrian Hymn, the oldest notated melodyThe tablet is a hymn to Nikkal with notation referring to the strings of a lyre, and it is the oldest substantially complete notated music. How it…
  14. 1867Marx's Das KapitalDas Kapital was a major critique of capitalism that influenced socialist movements, but its labor theory of value is rejected by most mainstream…
  15. 1913The Rite of Spring premieresThe 1913 premiere caused loud, sustained disruption in the audience, but accounts of the scale of violence vary and later retellings often grew.
  16. 1890Tango emerges in Buenos AiresTango formed in the 1880s and 1890s among the Rio de la Plata port cities from African, European and Cuban sources.
  17. 1832Galois and group theoryGalois was mortally wounded in a duel on May 30, 1832 and died the next day; why the duel took place is not settled.
  18. 1994Wiles proves Fermat's Last TheoremWiles's 1994 proof, completed with Taylor, uses twentieth century mathematics that Fermat could not have known.
  19. 1936BBC launches regular television serviceThe BBC's service of November 1936 was the first regular public high-definition television service, depending on how high-definition and regular are…
  20. 1920Scheduled radio broadcasting beginsKDKA began regular licensed broadcasting in 1920, one of several stations that began scheduled programs around the same time.
Drawer XIII

Artifacts that keep people arguing

Objects and documents whose origins or meaning are disputed.

  1. 1420Voynich manuscriptThe Voynich manuscript is an illustrated 15th-century codex in an unknown script that no one has convincingly deciphered.
  2. 1513Piri Reis mapThe Piri Reis map of 1513 is an Ottoman world map compiled from older sources, including a lost chart attributed to Columbus.
  3. 1882Donnelly revives AtlantisAtlantis comes from Plato's dialogues Timaeus and Critias, written around 360 BCE, and no archaeological evidence for it has been found.
  4. 1898Kensington Runestone foundThe Kensington Runestone, found on a Minnesota farm in 1898, bears a runic inscription dated 1362.
  5. 1988Shroud of Turin carbon-datedIn 1988 laboratories in Oxford, Zurich and Arizona radiocarbon-dated the Shroud of Turin to 1260 to 1390 CE.
  6. 1903Protocols of the Elders of Zion publishedThe Protocols of the Elders of Zion is a fabricated text first published in Russia in 1903 that purports to reveal a Jewish plan for world…
  7. 1983Hitler Diaries hoaxThe Hitler Diaries announced by Stern in April 1983 were forgeries written by Konrad Kujau, proven by the West German Federal Archives within two…
Drawer XIV

Signs in the sky

Comets, eclipses and lights in the sky, and what people made of them.

  1. 1566Basel celestial phenomenon of 1566A printed account describes black spheres crossing the sun over Basel on August 7, 1566. Scholars favor optical or atmospheric explanations, and the…
  2. 1456Halley's Comet of 1456 and the popePope Callixtus III is reported to have ordered prayers during the comet of 1456; the claim that he formally excommunicated it is a later legend.
  3. 1680Great Comet of 1680A single comet looped around the Sun in 1680 and 1681 on an orbit shaped by gravity; at the time people argued over whether it was one object and…
  4. 1919Eclipse of 1919 tests relativityThe 1919 eclipse plates favored Einstein's prediction over Newtonian bending, and later measurements confirm Einstein with high precision.
  5. 1913Great Meteor Procession of 1913A line of slow fireballs crossed North America on February 9, 1913, probably fragments of a small body that grazed the atmosphere; the exact origin…
  6. 1561Nuremberg celestial phenomenon of 1561A woodcut broadsheet records a dawn sky display over Nuremberg on April 14, 1561. Most scholars read it as a solar halo display, and spacecraft…
  7. 1054SN 1054 and the Crab NebulaChinese and Japanese records describe a supernova in 1054, and the Crab Nebula and its pulsar are its remnant; a few other claims about the star are…
  8. 185 CEGuest star of 185 CEMost astronomers think the guest star of 185 was a supernova linked to the remnant RCW 86, though the case rests on a single short record.
  9. 585 BCEEclipse of Thales stops a battleA total solar eclipse crossed Anatolia on May 28, 585 BCE and best fits Herodotus's story, but whether Thales truly predicted it is doubtful.
  10. 774 CECarbon-14 spike of 774 CEA burst of energetic particles hit Earth in 774 to 775 CE; what caused it, and whether any written source describes it, is not settled.
Drawer XV

Deep time debates

Fossils, extinctions and early Earth, where scientists still disagree about dates and causes.

  1. 4.2 GaLast universal common ancestorAll life shares one ancestral population of cells, but when it lived is uncertain.
  2. 3.9 GaLate Heavy BombardmentApollo samples cluster around 3.9 billion years, which some read as a burst of impacts.
  3. 66 MaDeccan Traps eruptThe Deccan Traps erupted in pulses around the time of the Chicxulub impact 66 million years ago.
  4. 1.3 MaHomo erectus reaches JavaWhen Homo erectus first reached Java depends on how the Sangiran layers are dated.
  5. 609 MaDoushantuo embryo fossilsThe Doushantuo spheres are real fossils of multicellular stages, but whether they are animal embryos is unresolved.
  6. 558 MaDickinsonia, the oldest confirmed animalChemical evidence from 2018 shows Dickinsonia was an animal, though its exact place within animals is not known.
  7. 555 MaKimberella, a slug-like early bilaterianKimberella is widely accepted as a bilaterian animal, but whether it was a mollusc is unsettled.
  8. 445 MaHirnantian glaciationA short, severe glaciation on southern Gondwana is well documented; what triggered it is not settled.
  9. 375 MaArchaeopteris, the first modern treesArchaeopteris was the first tree with modern wood and roots, but whether it caused Late Devonian ocean anoxia is unproven.
  10. 359 MaHangenberg extinctionA severe marine extinction at the end of the Devonian is well documented; its cause is debated.
  11. 335 MaTemnospondyls and early amphibiansTemnospondyls were the leading Paleozoic amphibians; the origin of living amphibians within or beside them is unresolved.
  12. 307 MaTully monsterTullimonstrum is a real soft-bodied animal from Mazon Creek; whether it was a vertebrate is unresolved.
  13. 300 MaGiant dragonfly-like insects and the oxygen peakGiant Carboniferous insects are real; whether high oxygen allowed their size is argued.
  14. 285 MaDimetrodon and the sail-backed synapsidsDimetrodon's sail is real and was supported by elongated spines; what it was for is debated.
  15. 262 MaCapitanian extinctionA biotic crisis occurred at the end of the Capitanian, near the time of Emeishan volcanism; its size and cause are debated.
  16. 220 MaFirst turtles: OdontochelysOdontochelys and Pappochelys show the shell built up in steps from broadened ribs and belly bones, but where turtles sit among reptiles is unsettled.
  17. 167 MaThe first snakesSnakes evolved from lizards by the Middle Jurassic, with the oldest fossils about 167 million years old, but how the first snakes lived is unresolved.
  18. 1861Archaeopteryx found at SolnhofenArchaeopteryx is a feathered dinosaur close to the origin of birds, with wings built for some kind of flight.
  19. 95 MaSpinosaurusSpinosaurus was a large fish-eating dinosaur adapted to water, but how far it swam is still contested.
  20. 67 MaTyrannosaurus rexTyrannosaurus rex was an apex predator that also scavenged, like many modern carnivores.
  21. 1969Ostrom's Deinonychus and the Dinosaur RenaissanceBirds descend from small feathered meat-eating dinosaurs, as Ostrom argued, and many dinosaurs were active animals.
  22. 120 MaMicroraptor, the four-winged dinosaurMicroraptor had four feathered wings and could glide, and many think it could also flap.
  23. 234 MaCarnian Pluvial EpisodeA wet climate shift occurred in the Carnian, probably triggered by volcanism, but its role in the dinosaurs' rise is under test.
  24. 68 MaTriceratopsTriceratops is a distinct dinosaur, while the status of the related Torosaurus is argued.
  25. 76 MaMaiasaura and the nesting groundsMaiasaura nested in colonies and cared for its young for some time, but the extent of parental care is debated.
  26. 52 MaFirst bats (Onychonycteris)Bats arose in the early Eocene, and the oldest fossils suggest flight evolved before echolocation.
  27. 17 MaHorses move onto the grasslandsHorses diversified into many grazers in the Miocene as grasslands spread, though the old ladder picture is wrong.
  28. 3.6 MaMegalodon dies outMegalodon died out in the Pliocene, several million years ago, probably because of climate and prey changes.
  29. 5.3 MaZanclean flood refills the MediterraneanThe Atlantic refilled the Mediterranean about 5.33 million years ago; the debate is how fast.
  30. 3.7 MaWoolly rhino ancestors on the Tibetan PlateauA 3.7 million year old woolly rhino relative lived in Tibet, but whether the plateau was the main cradle of ice age fauna is debated.
  31. 400 kaThe Irish elkThe Irish elk lived until about 10,900 years ago in Ireland and about 7,700 in Siberia; why it vanished is debated.
  32. 46 kaAustralia's megafauna dies outMost of Australia's large animals vanished soon after humans arrived about 50,000 years ago; the cause is argued.
  33. 2,000 BCELast mammoths on Wrangel IslandMammoths survived on Wrangel Island until about 4,000 years ago; the cause of their end is unknown.
  34. 12,600 BCEMeltwater Pulse 1ASea level rose several metres within centuries about 14,600 years ago; the source of the water is argued.
  35. 49 MaAzolla eventA fern bloom did occur in the Eocene Arctic; whether it helped cool the planet is debated.
Drawer XVI

Science and medicine under dispute

  1. 1920HIV-1 begins spreading in KinshasaHIV-1 descends from a chimpanzee virus (SIVcpz) that crossed into humans in west-central Africa in the early 20th century and spread from Kinshasa.
  2. 1998Retracted MMR autism paperLarge studies of millions of children find no link between the MMR vaccine and autism; the 1998 paper was retracted and found to rest on…
  3. 1996GM crops go mainstreamMajor scientific bodies find approved GM crops as safe to eat as conventional ones; debates continue over ecology, herbicide use and corporate…
  4. 2000Golden RiceGolden Rice reliably produces beta-carotene, but whether it would make a large difference to vitamin A deficiency in practice remains unproven.
  5. 1948Alpher and Gamow's hot Big BangThe universe expanded from a hot, dense early state about 13.8 billion years ago; the CMB and light-element abundances are the key evidence.
  6. 1942Modern evolutionary synthesisNatural selection acting on genetic variation is the core mechanism of adaptive evolution, as the modern synthesis holds.
  7. 1967Endosymbiotic theoryMitochondria and chloroplasts descend from bacteria taken into ancestral cells.
  8. 1450Coffee drinking begins in YemenCoffee plants are native to Ethiopia, but the earliest reliable evidence of coffee as a brewed drink comes from Sufi circles in Yemen in the…
  9. 800 CENew crops spread across the Islamic worldNew crops and irrigation methods did spread across the early Islamic world, but whether this amounted to a revolution is debated.
  10. 1957Project PlowshareAtomic Energy Commission and national laboratory records document Plowshare's tests and results. The program's environmental effects, especially…
  11. 1954Operation WhitecoatArmy and church records confirm Whitecoat used consenting volunteers and recorded no deaths. Debate continues over long term health effects and…
  12. 1951Nevada Test Site and the downwindersGovernment records, a 1997 National Cancer Institute study and the 1990 compensation law establish that fallout from Nevada tests exposed downwind…
  13. 1912Piltdown Man forgeryPiltdown Man, announced in 1912 as an early human ancestor, was proven in 1953 to be a forgery assembled from a medieval human skull, an orangutan…
Drawer XVII

Collapses and catastrophes

  1. 476 CEFall of the Western Roman EmpireThe Western Empire collapsed through a long mix of internal and external pressures.
  2. 900 CEClassic Maya collapseMaya cities in the southern lowlands were largely abandoned between about 800 and 950, though Maya people and cities elsewhere continued.
  3. 1347Black DeathCaused by the bacterium Yersinia pestis, confirmed by DNA from plague victims' teeth.
  4. 1912Titanic sinksThe Titanic struck an iceberg on 14 April 1912 and sank within three hours.
  5. 2020COVID-19 pandemicSARS-CoV-2 emerged in Wuhan, China, in late 2019. How it first infected people remains unresolved.
Drawer XVIII

Popes, saints and miracles

Church history where the record, the tradition and the skeptics disagree. Miracle claims are labeled by what can be shown, not by faith either way.

  1. 760 CEDonation of Constantine forgedThe Donation of Constantine is a forgery, not a grant by Constantine; Lorenzo Valla demonstrated this in 1440 and no serious scholar defends it.
  2. 1255Pope Joan legend appearsNo contemporary evidence shows a female pope; the story first appears in chronicles of the 1250s and historians treat it as legend.
  3. 1531Apparition of Our Lady of GuadalupeDevotion to Our Lady of Guadalupe at Tepeyac is documented from the mid-1550s, but the full apparition story first appears in print in 1648 and 1649.
  4. 1389First recorded liquefaction of the blood of St JanuariusA dark substance in a sealed ampoule in Naples has been seen to turn from solid to liquid during public ceremonies since at least 1389.
  5. 1917Miracle of the Sun at FatimaOn 13 October 1917 a large crowd at Fatima, reported in Portuguese newspapers, described seeing the sun move, spin and change color.
  6. 1939Pius XII electedPius XII knew of the mass murder of Jews by 1942 and did not publicly name and condemn it; historians disagree about his reasons and about how much…
  7. 1978John Paul I's 33-day papacyJohn Paul I died suddenly in his bed on the night of 28 September 1978; no autopsy was performed, and the Vatican's initial accounts of how he was…
  8. 1981Assassination attempt on John Paul IIMehmet Ali Agca shot John Paul II on 13 May 1981 and was convicted; who, if anyone, stood behind him has never been established.
  9. 2016Teresa of Calcutta canonizedThe Church credited Mother Teresa's intercession with two cures, and the first, Monica Besra's in 1998, has been disputed by doctors who treated her.
Drawer XIX

Sport and spectacle

  1. 1988Ben Johnson stripped of Olympic goldBen Johnson used anabolic steroids, as he and his coach admitted under oath at Canada's Dubin Inquiry in 1989.
  2. 2012Lance Armstrong stripped of Tour titlesLance Armstrong doped during his Tour de France wins; USADA documented it in 2012 and he admitted it in 2013.
  3. 2016Russian state doping exposedIndependent investigations found that Russian officials ran a doping cover-up that included swapping samples at the 2014 Sochi Olympics.
  4. 1938The War of the Worlds broadcastThe 1938 broadcast frightened some listeners, but the nationwide mass panic described in next-day newspapers was far smaller than reported.
  5. 1999EmojiShigetaka Kurita's 1999 set for NTT Docomo was the most influential early emoji set, though not the earliest.
  6. 1665Vermeer's Girl with a Pearl EarringVermeer's paintings show optical effects associated with the camera obscura, but how, or whether, he used one is unresolved.
Drawer XX

Modern disputes

  1. 1969Moon landingTwelve astronauts walked on the Moon between 1969 and 1972.
  2. 2023Ordinals, inscriptions and Bitcoin tokensInscriptions are valid under Bitcoin's consensus rules and have paid substantial fees to miners. Whether nodes should relay them is one of the most…
Reading room

Declassified archives

Primary sources straight from the agencies. Anyone can link documents from these collections to any event.

Know a case that belongs here?

Members with reputation and supporters can propose new events, and anyone can add notes and sources to these files.