Sign in
War & ConflictWorld Wars and the Atom

Shelling of Mainila

1939Claims checked

On November 26, 1939, the Soviet Union said Finnish artillery had shelled the border village of Mainila and killed Soviet soldiers. Finland denied it, and four days later the Red Army invaded, starting the Winter War.

The story

On November 26, 1939, Soviet authorities announced that Finnish artillery had fired seven shells at the village of Mainila on the Karelian Isthmus, killing four Red Army soldiers and wounding nine. Moscow demanded that Finland pull its troops back from the border. The Finnish government replied that its guns had been withdrawn out of range, and that its border guards had seen the shells land from the Soviet side. Finland proposed a joint investigation. Instead, the Soviet Union renounced its nonaggression treaty with Finland, and on November 30 the Red Army invaded, starting the Winter War.

The background was the Nazi-Soviet Pact of August 1939, whose secret protocol placed Finland in the Soviet sphere. After Finland refused Stalin's demands to cede territory near Leningrad, Soviet leaders needed a pretext. Finnish observation posts recorded seven shots exploding about 800 meters inside Soviet territory, and modern historians conclude the shelling was staged by the NKVD, the Soviet security police, pointing also to papers of the Leningrad party chief Andrei Zhdanov. In 1994 Russian president Boris Yeltsin called the Winter War a war of aggression, and the phrase Mainila shots became a Finnish byword for a manufactured excuse.

Why it mattered

  • The incident gave the Soviet Union its pretext for the Winter War, in which Finland held out for 105 days and lost about a tenth of its territory.
  • Finland's costly survival shaped its later wartime alignment with Germany and its postwar policy of careful neutrality toward Moscow.
  • Mainila became a standard reference point whenever Russia announced provocations before later military operations.

Sources

  1. 'Impudent Provocation by Finnish Warmongers': The Shelling of Mainila (1939) in the Context of Soviet / Russian Propaganda and Information Warfare AREI (Kati Parppei)
  2. The start of the Winter War Museo Militaria
  3. Mainila shelling Yle
  4. DISINFO: Finland provoked the war against Soviet Union in 1939, Soviet leadership stated EUvsDisinfo

Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made

Claims checked against the record

Consensus: The Soviet Union blamed Finland for shelling Mainila on November 26, 1939, and invaded four days later. Finnish observers at the time and most later historians conclude the shelling was staged on the Soviet side, though no written Soviet order has been published.

Finnish artillery did not fire the shellsEstablished
Finnish guns had been moved out of range of the village on Mannerheim's orders, and three observation posts recorded the shells exploding about 800 meters inside Soviet territory. Historians in Finland and Russia broadly accept that the Finnish army was not responsible.
Read this view
The shelling was a deliberate Soviet provocation to justify warEstablished
Modern historians conclude the NKVD staged it, citing the Finnish observations, the timing, and material in the archive of Soviet leader Andrei Zhdanov showing the incident was planned to cast Finland as the aggressor. Russia does not officially acknowledge a staged attack, but President Yeltsin called the war Soviet aggression in 1994.
Read this view
Finland provoked the war by attacking firstDebunked
This was the official Soviet account and is still repeated in some Russian outlets, but it is contradicted by the Finnish records and by Russia's own acknowledgement in the 1990s that the war was Soviet aggression.
Where this claim comes from, and its rebuttals

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

BookWilliam R. Trotter
A Frozen Hell
Editor's pick
VideoSearch on YouTube
Shelling of Mainila Winter War documentary
Editor's pick