Sign in

Donation of Constantine forged

c. 760 CEContested

A document claiming Constantine gave the pope rule over Rome and the western empire is composed, probably in the 8th century. Popes and canonists cited it for centuries.

The story

The Donation of Constantine (Constitutum Constantini) is a Latin document, composed probably in Rome in the 700s or early 800s, that claims to be a decree of the Roman emperor Constantine the Great. In it, Constantine, cured of leprosy by Pope Sylvester I, gives the pope the Lateran palace, a place of honor above the other great bishops of the church, and rule over Rome, Italy and 'the regions of the West' while he himself moves to the East. None of this happened. The text was forged by someone in the papal circle at a time when the popes, who had just turned from the Byzantine emperors to the Franks, needed a founding legend for their independent power.

For centuries it passed as genuine. Popes and canon lawyers cited it, and the great collection of church law compiled by Gratian included it in the 1100s. Pope Leo IX used it in 1054 in his quarrel with Constantinople. It was exposed in the 1400s, when Nicholas of Cusa and Lorenzo Valla, a humanist scholar, showed that its Latin used words and ideas that did not exist in Constantine's day, and that no earlier source mentions it. Valla's treatise, published in 1517, was seized upon by Protestant writers. The forgery remains a famous example of how historical criticism can overturn an authority.

Why it mattered

  • Papal claims to rule in the West gained a historical foundation that medieval popes and lawyers used in disputes with emperors.
  • The exposure of the forgery by Lorenzo Valla showed that careful study of language could test the claims of powerful institutions.
  • Reformation writers used Valla's work as ammunition against papal authority in the 1500s.
  • The case helped establish the methods of historical criticism, including the study of anachronism and the checking of sources.

Sources

  1. Donation of Constantine World History Encyclopedia
  2. Donation of Constantine (Catholic Encyclopedia) New Advent / Catholic Encyclopedia
  3. Donation of Constantine and Constitutum Constantini (review of Fried) Bryn Mawr Classical Review

Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made

Contested history

Consensus: The Donation of Constantine is a forgery, not a grant by Constantine; Lorenzo Valla demonstrated this in 1440 and no serious scholar defends it.

Genuine fourth-century grant by ConstantineDebunked
Its Latin, titles and references belong to centuries after Constantine, as Valla and later philologists showed.
Where this claim comes from, and its rebuttals
Composed in Rome in the mid-8th century, around the papal turn to the FranksDebated
Many historians link it to the 750s to 770s papal chancery, but the oldest copy is 9th century and dating estimates range widely.
Read this view
Composed in the Frankish kingdom in the 9th centuryMinority view
Some scholars point to Frankish manuscript transmission and context, but most still favor a Roman origin.

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

Documentbritannica.com
Donation of Constantine (Britannica)
Editor's pick
BookLorenzo Valla, trans. G. W. Bowersock
On the Donation of Constantine
Search Open Library
VideoSearch YouTube
Donation of Constantine forgery explained
Search YouTube
VideoSearch YouTube
Medieval forgeries Donation of Constantine
Search YouTube