Sign in

Pope Joan legend appears

c. 1255Claims checked

Chronicles of the mid-13th century begin telling of a woman who reigned as pope in disguise. No earlier source records her, and historians regard the story as legend.

The story

In the middle of the thirteenth century, chroniclers began to tell of a woman who had served as pope in disguise. The story, first written down by Dominican writers such as Jean de Mailly and made famous by Martin of Opava (Martinus Polonus) in the 1260s and 1270s, says that a learned woman from Mainz dressed as a man, rose through the Church, and was elected pope around 855, between Leo IV and Benedict III. She is said to have been discovered when she gave birth during a procession through Rome, and to have died soon afterward.

No source from the 9th, 10th, 11th or 12th century mentions her, and the records leave no gap. Leo IV died on July 17, 855, and Benedict III was chosen within weeks, with coins and letters of the period supporting this. Historians therefore regard the story as a legend, whose origins may lie in satire of the papacy or in tales of powerful women in tenth-century Rome. It was widely believed for centuries, and Pope Joan was even included among the carved papal busts in Siena Cathedral. In the sixteenth century Protestants used the tale against Rome, and in 1647 the Protestant scholar David Blondel took apart the story, after which it lost credibility.

Why it mattered

  • The legend became a vehicle for criticism of the papacy, especially in the Reformation, when Protestants cited it as proof of corruption.
  • It led to later stories about a ritual test of the pope's sex, which are also considered to be untrue.
  • It showed how a legend could pass as history in medieval chronicles, through repeated copying.
  • Its debunking in the seventeenth century became a standard example of critical historical method.

Sources

  1. Pope Joan Britannica
  2. Pope Joan World History Encyclopedia
  3. Catholic Encyclopedia: Pope Joan New Advent

Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made

Claims checked against the record

Consensus: No contemporary evidence shows a female pope; the story first appears in chronicles of the 1250s and historians treat it as legend.

A woman disguised as a man reigned as pope in the 9th centuryUnsupported
Papal lists, letters and coins of the period leave no gap for her, and no source mentions her until about 400 years later.
Where this claim comes from, and its rebuttals
The legend grew from Roman folklore and later anti-papal useEstablished
It spread through Martin of Opava's popular chronicle and was taken up by Protestant polemicists before scholars, including Protestant ones, rejected it.
Read this view

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

Documentbritannica.com
Pope Joan (Britannica)
Editor's pick
BookAlain Boureau
The Myth of Pope Joan
Search Open Library
VideoSearch YouTube
Pope Joan legend explained
Search YouTube
VideoSearch YouTube
Was there a female pope
Search YouTube