The story
In September 440 CE, while he was away in Gaul trying to reconcile two Roman generals, a deacon named Leo was chosen as bishop of Rome. He took office on September 29 and served for 21 years, until his death in 461. Leo is remembered as the pope who argued most forcefully that the bishop of Rome had authority over the whole church, because he held the place of the apostle Peter. He is one of the few popes given the title 'the Great'.
The background was Rome's changing position. The emperors lived in Ravenna and Constantinople, and the city's old civil leaders were fading, so the church was becoming the city's most stable institution. Christians had long honored Rome because Peter and Paul were thought to have died there. Leo taught that Christ had placed Peter at the head of the apostles and that the bishop of Rome inherited Peter's role, so that when he spoke, Peter spoke through him. In 445 the western emperor Valentinian III issued an order backing the pope's authority over the bishops of the West.
Leo also took part in the great controversies of his day. In 449 he wrote a letter, the Tome, to the bishop of Constantinople, setting out that Christ is one person with two natures, divine and human. At the Council of Chalcedon in 451, the bishops hailed it, as later tradition has it, with the cry 'Peter has spoken through Leo'. In 452, he led an embassy to Attila the Hun near Mantua, and the invader turned back from Italy, though disease, supply problems and imperial pressure probably mattered too. In 455 he persuaded the Vandal king Geiseric to spare the lives of Romans and the city's churches when Rome was looted, though it was plundered for two weeks.
Why it mattered
- The Council of Chalcedon adopted his Tome in 451 as the basis of its definition of Christ.
- Meeting Attila became a famous episode that later built the image of the pope as the city's defender.
- Gelasius I's letter on the two powers later developed Leo's claim for church authority.
- Stephen II turned to the Franks for protection, as popes took on the political role that Leo had begun to show.
- The Pope Joan legend arose centuries later, in a Europe where the papacy's prestige was great enough to be an object of satire and rumor.
Sources
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…