Sign in

Council of Chalcedon

451 CEBig moment

The council defines Christ as one person in two natures, divine and human. Churches in Egypt, Syria and Armenia reject it, causing a lasting split between Chalcedonian and Oriental Orthodox Christians.

The story

In autumn 451 CE, about 500 bishops met in Chalcedon, a town across the Bosphorus from Constantinople, for the fourth ecumenical council of the church. Called by the emperor Marcian, and with his wife Pulcheria taking a leading part, the council defined that Christ is one person in two natures, fully divine and fully human, 'without confusion, without change, without division, without separation'. The council's decision became the standard of most Christian churches, but it also caused a lasting split.

The question of how divinity and humanity are joined in Jesus had divided the church since Nicaea in 325. The Council of Ephesus in 431 had condemned Nestorius for appearing to divide Christ into two persons. Then an abbot named Eutyches was accused of the opposite fault, blurring the two natures into one, and in 449 a council at Ephesus under the bishop Dioscorus of Alexandria cleared him and deposed his critic Flavian of Constantinople, a meeting that Leo I of Rome called a 'robbery' and critics a 'robber synod'. Leo's Tome supplied the answer: two natures, one person. After Marcian became emperor in 450, a new council was called to reverse the earlier verdict.

The bishops deposed Dioscorus, approved the Tome and issued the definition, and Canon 28 granted the see of Constantinople honors second only to Rome, which Leo refused to accept. In Egypt, Syria and Armenia, many Christians felt the decision betrayed Cyril of Alexandria's teaching of 'one nature of the incarnate Word', and they rejected it. The result was a lasting separation between the Chalcedonian churches (Catholic, Eastern Orthodox and most Protestants) and the Oriental Orthodox churches (Coptic, Syriac, Armenian, Ethiopian, Eritrean and Malankara). In recent decades, theologians on both sides have concluded that the dispute rested largely on different uses of words, though the churches have not reunited.

Why it mattered

  • The Church of the East, which stood outside the Roman Empire's councils, expanded eastward across Asia, as in its mission to China, in a world already divided over Christ's nature.
  • Divisions between the Oriental Orthodox and others shaped the religious map of Egypt, Syria and Armenia under later empires and Muslim rule.
  • Oriental Orthodox communities, such as the Coptic church, kept their own traditions, as seen in the 21 Coptic martyrs of Libya in 2015.
  • The formula of one person in two natures became a standard of orthodoxy for the Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant churches.

Sources

  1. Council of Chalcedon Britannica
  2. Council of Chalcedon World History Encyclopedia
  3. Tome Britannica
  4. Eutyches Britannica

Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

Documentbritannica.com
Council of Chalcedon (Britannica)
Editor's pick
BookHenry Chadwick
The Early Church
Search Open Library
VideoSearch YouTube
Council of Chalcedon explained
Search YouTube