Sign in
The Classical WorldCosmos & Earth

Eclipse of Thales stops a battle

585 BCEMajorContested

A total solar eclipse darkens the sky in the middle of a battle between Lydians and Medes in Anatolia. Herodotus says Thales had foretold the year, and the armies made peace.

The story

In the account of the Greek historian Herodotus, the Lydians under King Alyattes and the Medes under King Cyaxares had been at war in Anatolia (modern Turkey) for five years without a decisive result. In the sixth year, in the middle of a battle, day suddenly turned to night. Both armies stopped fighting, and the kings agreed to peace. The agreement was sealed by a marriage between Alyattes' daughter Aryenis and Cyaxares' son Astyages, and the Halys River became the border. Herodotus adds that Thales of Miletus had told the Ionian Greeks in advance which year the darkness would come.

Astronomers who have computed ancient eclipse paths find that a total eclipse of the Sun crossed Anatolia on May 28, 585 BCE, which makes it the best match. That turns a story into one of the earliest firm dates in Greek and Near Eastern history, and scholars use it to date Thales and the Lydian and Median kingdoms. How Thales could have known is unclear. Babylonian astronomers had kept eclipse records for centuries (see the Babylonian astronomical diaries) and may have noticed that eclipses repeat after a cycle of about 18 years, later called the Saros, though it was probably not yet reliable for prediction. But a cycle tells you an eclipse is possible somewhere, not that it will be total over a particular country, so many historians doubt that any real prediction was possible.

Herodotus wrote about 150 years after the event, so the tale may have grown in the telling, and some older studies proposed other eclipses. Even so, later Greek writers made it the founding story of Greek science: a thinker who could read the sky without gods or omens. The eclipse itself remains a rare case where a physical event fixes a date for the ancient world.

Why it mattered

  • Provided an astronomical anchor date that historians use to fix early Greek, Lydian and Median chronology.
  • Made Thales a symbol of predictive, natural explanation, a story later Greek philosophers and historians repeated.
  • Showed that Babylonian eclipse knowledge could travel west to Ionian Greek scholars.
  • Set an early template for the eclipse as a moment that stops human affairs, retold from Columbus to the movies.

Contested history

Consensus: A total solar eclipse crossed Anatolia on May 28, 585 BCE and best fits Herodotus's story, but whether Thales truly predicted it is doubtful.

An eclipse on May 28, 585 BCE ended the battleEstablished
Computed eclipse paths show a total eclipse over Asia Minor that day, and most chronologists accept the match.
Thales predicted the eclipse from Babylonian cyclesDebated
He may have known eclipse cycles, but they could not say where an eclipse would be visible, and Herodotus wrote long afterwards.
Read this view
The darkness was another eclipse, such as one in 610 BCEMinority view
Some older scholarship argued for other dates, but the 585 BCE eclipse is now generally preferred.
Read this view

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

BookRobert B. Strassler (ed.)
The Landmark Herodotus ↗
Editor's pick
BookMark Littmann, Fred Espenak and Ken Willcox
Totality: Eclipses of the Sun ↗
Editor's pick
VideoSearch on YouTube
eclipse of Thales battle of the Halys ↗
Editor's pick
VideoSearch on YouTube
Thales predicted eclipse 585 BC ↗
Editor's pick