Sign in
Industrial AgeGovernment & Law

Haymarket affair and May Day

1886MajorContested

A bomb explodes at a Chicago rally for the eight-hour day on May 4, 1886; the trial of eight anarchists ends in executions, and May 1 becomes International Workers' Day.

The story

On May 4, 1886, several thousand people gathered at Haymarket Square in Chicago, in a rally in support of striking workers and the eight-hour day. As police moved to disperse the dwindling crowd, someone threw a bomb, which killed police officer Mathias Degan and fatally wounded others; police opened fire, and in the confusion seven officers and at least four civilians died in all. The bomber was never identified. The rally came a day after police had killed at least two strikers outside the McCormick Reaper Works.

Workers were then pressing for the eight-hour day, and the Federation of Organized Trades and Labor Unions had set May 1, 1886 for a national strike, in which more than 300,000 workers took part. Chicago's labor movement was among the most radical in the country, with an active anarchist press among German immigrants, and employers and newspapers feared revolution. Chicago police arrested hundreds of radicals, and eight anarchists were tried. Evidence linking them to the bomb was weak, and several were not present when it exploded. Seven were sentenced to death and one to fifteen years. The governor commuted two sentences, one man killed himself in his cell, and four, including August Spies and Albert Parsons, were hanged on November 11, 1887. Governor John Peter Altgeld pardoned the three survivors in 1893, saying the trial had been unfair.

The affair set back the American eight-hour movement and fed a wave of anti-radical feeling, but it made martyrs for labor movements worldwide. In 1889 the Second International, meeting in Paris, called for annual demonstrations on May 1, in honor of the 1886 strike, and May Day became International Workers' Day, a holiday in most of the world. In the United States, where the Labor Day holiday in September was established in 1894, May Day is not an official holiday. The Haymarket monument in Chicago's Forest Home cemetery marks the graves of the men.

Why it mattered

  • May 1 became International Workers' Day after the Second International called for demonstrations in 1889, first held in 1890.
  • The trial became a symbol of unfair justice and of the repression of labor activism, fueling worldwide labor solidarity.
  • The anti-radical backlash damaged the Knights of Labor, helping the American Federation of Labor under Samuel Gompers to become the main union body.
  • The eight-hour day, which Haymarket's rally demanded, was gradually won in the following decades.

Contested history

Consensus: A bomb was thrown at police at the May 4, 1886 rally, but the thrower was never identified, and most historians judge that the trial convicted the eight anarchists mainly for their beliefs, not for proven acts.

The convicted men were not shown to have planned or thrown the bombEstablished
Prosecutors had no evidence linking the defendants to the bomber, and Governor Altgeld's 1893 pardon found the trial unfair.
The bomb was thrown by an anarchist acting on the movement's violent rhetoricDebated
Some contemporaries and later writers argue anarchist speeches and publications incited violence, though the thrower's identity remains unknown.
Read this view
The bomb was thrown by a police agent provocateurUnsupported
The theory has been advanced, but no documentary evidence has been found.
Read this view

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

BookJames Green
Death in the Haymarket ↗
Editor's pick
BookPaul Avrich
The Haymarket Tragedy ↗
Editor's pick
VideoSearch on YouTube
Haymarket affair 1886 history explained ↗
Editor's pick
VideoSearch on YouTube
origin of May Day International Workers Day ↗
Editor's pick