Sign in
The Classical WorldCosmos & Earth

Guest star of 185 CE

185 CENotableContested

Han court astronomers record a guest star in December 185 that stays visible for about eight months. Many astronomers now link it to the supernova remnant RCW 86.

The story

The Book of the Later Han reports that in the tenth month of the second year of the Zhongping reign, a guest star appeared in the Southern Gate, a group of stars in the region of Centaurus. Chinese astronomers called new stars that stayed in one place guest stars, in contrast to broom stars, which moved. The record gives the date as December 185 CE, and says the star faded away after about eight months.

A new star that lasts months without moving points to a supernova, the explosion of a star. In 2006 and later, X-ray astronomers argued that the remnant RCW 86, about 8,000 light years away, has an age close to 1,800 years, which matches the record. Not everyone accepts the link, since the entry is short and a bright comet without a tail is not ruled out. If the match is right, this is the oldest supernova known from a written record.

Why it mattered

  • Gave astronomers the oldest likely supernova match between a written record and a remnant.
  • Let researchers test remnant ages against historical dates, a method used for SN 1006 and SN 1054.
  • Showed the value of the Chinese court's careful sky logs for modern astrophysics.

Sources

  1. RCW 86 Chandra X-ray Center
  2. 'Supernova' 185 is really a nova plus Comet P/Swift-Tuttle (Bradley Schaefer, 1995) Louisiana State University repository
  3. The First Supernova Smithsonian Magazine

Contested history

Consensus: Most astronomers think the guest star of 185 was a supernova linked to the remnant RCW 86, though the case rests on a single short record.

It was a supernova that left the remnant RCW 86Debated
The remnant's measured age fits, but the match depends on one brief Chinese entry and on remnant dating methods.
Read this view
It was a comet without a visible tailMinority view
A stationary object lasting eight months fits a supernova far better than any known comet.

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

BookF. Richard Stephenson and David A. Green
Historical Supernovae and Their Remnants ↗
Editor's pick
VideoSearch on YouTube
supernova 185 AD RCW 86 ↗
Editor's pick
VideoSearch on YouTube
guest star Chinese astronomers supernova ↗
Editor's pick