Sign in
Deep TimeLife & Evolution

First turtles: Odontochelys

220 million years agoNotableContested

Odontochelys, a toothed turtle with a belly shell but no back shell, shows how the turtle body plan was built step by step in the Late Triassic.

The story

Odontochelys semitestacea, described by Li Chun and colleagues in 2008 from the Xiaowa Formation of Guizhou, China, is a turtle about 40 cm long from roughly 220 million years ago. It has a complete belly shell (plastron) and widened ribs, but no full domed carapace, and it still has teeth in its jaws, unlike later turtles with horny beaks. Its name means toothed turtle with a half shell.

Earlier fossils fill in the steps. Eunotosaurus from the Permian of South Africa has broad ribs, Pappochelys from the German Middle Triassic has belly ribs that began forming a plastron, and Proganochelys, about 210 million years old, has a full shell, though it still has teeth on its palate and cannot pull its head in. Where turtles sit among reptiles is still debated, but genetic data link them with the archosaurs, the lineage of crocodiles and birds. Turtles passed through every extinction since and survive today.

Why it mattered

  • Odontochelys showed that the plastron formed before the carapace, settling a long debate about how the shell evolved.
  • Turtles are among the oldest living reptile lineages and survived the end-Triassic and end-Cretaceous extinctions.
  • Their fossil sequence shows how a drastically new body plan can build up from small changes in the ribs.

Contested history

Consensus: Odontochelys and Pappochelys show the shell built up in steps from broadened ribs and belly bones, but where turtles sit among reptiles is unsettled.

Turtles are related to the archosaurs (crocodiles and birds)Debated
Most DNA analyses place turtles near archosaurs, but this conflicts with some anatomy-based trees.
Turtles sit near lizards and snakes within diapsid reptilesDebated
Some fossil-based analyses link them to lepidosaurs, and the question is not fully settled.
Odontochelys lived in the sea, so early turtles were marineDebated
Its beds are coastal, but Eunotosaurus and Pappochelys suggest a land or burrowing origin for the shell.
Read this view

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

BookJeanette Wyneken, Matthew H. Godfrey and Vincent Bels
Biology of Turtles ↗
Editor's pick
BookBrian Switek
Written in Stone ↗
Editor's pick
VideoSearch on YouTube
Odontochelys first turtle toothed ↗
Editor's pick
VideoSearch on YouTube
how the turtle shell evolved ↗
Editor's pick