Sign in

Pius XII elected

1939Big momentContested

Eugenio Pacelli, the Vatican's secretary of state, is elected in a one-day conclave months before World War II. His wartime conduct remains one of the most debated questions in papal history.

The story

On March 2, 1939, after a conclave of only one day, the cardinals elected Eugenio Pacelli, aged 63, as pope. He took the name Pius XII. Pope Pius XI had died on February 10, and Pacelli, who as Cardinal Secretary of State had run the Vatican's diplomacy since 1930, was elected on the third ballot. It was the first time since 1667 that a Secretary of State had become pope. Six months later World War II began.

Pacelli came from a Roman family of Church lawyers. He had worked in the Vatican diplomatic service, served as nuncio, or papal ambassador, in Germany from 1917 to 1929, and had helped negotiate treaties with several governments, including the concordat with Nazi Germany in 1933. He was close to Pius XI and had been involved in the Lateran Treaty of 1929, through his brother Francesco, who helped negotiate it. In the conclave of 1939 the cardinals wanted an experienced diplomat to steer the Church through the coming storm.

His wartime conduct is one of the most debated questions in papal history. He kept the Vatican neutral, appealed for peace, and in his 1942 Christmas message spoke of the hundreds of thousands who were killed or persecuted because of nationality or race, without naming Jews or Germany. Supporters point to the Church's hiding of thousands of Jews in convents and Vatican buildings, and to the fear that open protest would bring worse reprisals. Critics, beginning with Rolf Hochhuth's 1963 play The Deputy, say he failed to speak out clearly, including during the roundup of Roman Jews in October 1943. The Vatican opened its archives for his pontificate to researchers in March 2020, and historians continue to study them. Pius XII died on October 9, 1958, and was succeeded by John XXIII.

Why it mattered

  • The debate over the Church's response to the Holocaust shaped postwar Catholic-Jewish relations, leading to the Second Vatican Council's declaration Nostra Aetate in 1965.
  • His successor John XXIII, elected in 1958, called the Second Vatican Council, which reformed the Church.
  • The opening of the Vatican archives in 2020 gave historians new evidence on his wartime decisions.
  • Pius XII's definition of the dogma of the Assumption of Mary in 1950 remains the most recent use of papal infallibility.

Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made

Contested history

Consensus: Pius XII knew of the mass murder of Jews by 1942 and did not publicly name and condemn it; historians disagree about his reasons and about how much of the Church's rescue work he directed. The Vatican opened his pontificate's archives in March 2020.

The Vatican received detailed reports of mass killings during the warEstablished
Wartime diplomatic files and documents released since 2020 show reports reaching the Secretariat of State in 1942.
Silence was a deliberate choice to avoid reprisals and protect Catholics and Jews in hidingDebated
Defenders cite the Dutch deportations after bishops protested in 1942; critics argue a clear public statement could have saved lives.
Church institutions in Rome sheltered thousands of Jews in 1943 and 1944Established
Convents, monasteries and Vatican properties hid Jews during the German occupation; whether Pius ordered this directly is debated.
Pius XII was sympathetic to NazismUnsupported
His 1937 drafting role in Mit brennender Sorge and his contacts with anti-Hitler plotters cut against this; John Cornwell later softened his 'Hitler's Pope' thesis.

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

Documentbritannica.com
Pius XII (Britannica)
Editor's pick
Documentvaticannews.va
Opening of the Pius XII archives (Vatican News)
Editor's pick
BookDavid I. Kertzer
The Pope at War
Search Open Library
BookJohn Cornwell
Hitler's Pope
Search Open Library
BookDavid G. Dalin
The Myth of Hitler's Pope
Search Open Library
VideoSearch YouTube
Pius XII and the Holocaust debate
Search YouTube
VideoSearch YouTube
Pius XII Vatican archives revelations
Search YouTube