Sign in

USS Nimitz "Tic Tac" encounter

2004Contested

In November 2004 Navy pilots from the USS Nimitz carrier group track and chase a white, oblong object off southern California that they cannot identify.

The story

In November 2004, during exercises about 100 miles off San Diego, radar aboard the cruiser USS Princeton, part of the USS Nimitz carrier group, picked up objects that seemed to descend from great height and hover. On November 14, Commander David Fravor and Lieutenant Commander Alex Dietrich, flying F/A-18 fighters, were sent to look. Fravor described a white, smooth, oblong object about 40 feet long, shaped like a Tic Tac mint, moving above a patch of disturbed water. When he turned toward it, the object accelerated away, and was then picked up on radar again at a point far from where it was.

The event stayed unknown to the public until December 2017, when the New York Times and others reported on a Pentagon study of such sightings, and the Navy confirmed in 2019 and 2020 that videos were authentic. A 2021 report from the Director of National Intelligence on 'unidentified aerial phenomena' did not explain most cases. Radar made the observation possible, and it also raises questions about how reliably instruments and human eyes work. Skeptics point to sensor errors or conventional aircraft, and pilots say they saw something that outperformed any known aircraft. No agency has produced a confirmed explanation, and nothing in the record demonstrates origins beyond Earth.

Why it mattered

  • The Pentagon revealed its program to study unidentified aerial phenomena, bringing the topic into official discussion.
  • Congress held hearings on unidentified aerial phenomena, and the defense department set up a dedicated office.
  • Military pilots gained new channels to report unexplained sightings without stigma.
  • The episode renewed scientific interest in better sensors for studying unexplained phenomena.

Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made

Contested history

Consensus: Experienced pilots and radar operators reported an object they could not identify. The Navy has never publicly explained it, and the full radar data has not been released.

Sensor artifacts or conventional aircraftDebated
Skeptics such as Mick West argue the released videos are consistent with distant aircraft and camera effects. The pilots' eyewitness accounts are harder to explain this way.
Advanced foreign or secret U.S. technologySpeculation
No public evidence ties the object to any nation's program.
A non-human craftUnsupported
No physical evidence or released sensor data shows this.

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

VideoSearch YouTube
USS Nimitz Tic Tac encounter pilots interview
Search YouTube