Halley's Comet of 1456 and the pope

1456NotableContested

Halley's Comet returns in June 1456, three years after Constantinople fell. A later legend says Pope Callixtus III excommunicated it; the pope did order prayers.

Longest chain: The Big Bang → First atomic nuclei form → First stars ignite → First galaxies assemble → Milky Way takes shape → The Sun forms → Earth forms → First oceans → First life → Photosynthesis evolves → Great Oxidation Event → Complex cells (eukaryotes) → Multicellular life → First animals → Cambrian Explosion → First vertebrates → Jawed fish → Lobe-finned fish → Fish walk onto land → The amniotic egg → The Great Dying → Dinosaurs appear → End-Triassic extinction → Pangaea breaks apart → Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum → Early primates → First anthropoid primates → Apes split from monkeys → Great apes split from gibbons → Human line splits from chimpanzees → Walking upright → First stone tools → Genus Homo appears → Homo erectus → Control of fire → Habitual fire and cooking → Homo sapiens appears → Complex language → Natufian villages → Oldest known bread → Agriculture begins → Irrigation → Uruk and the first cities → Cylinder seals → Writing (cuneiform) → Egyptian hieroglyphs → The alphabet → Phoenician alphabet → Greek alphabet → Solon's reforms → Athenian democracy → Trial and death of Socrates → Plato's Academy → Aristotle's Lyceum → Alexander's conquests → Death of Alexander and the Hellenistic kingdoms → Seleucid Empire founded → Parthian Empire founded → Sasanian Empire → Crisis of the Third Century → Diocletian's Tetrarchy → Diocletian's Great Persecution → Edict of Milan → Constantinople founded → Roman Empire permanently divides → Visigoths sack Rome → Fall of the Western Roman Empire → Clovis unites the Franks → Stephen II anoints Pepin and seeks Frankish aid → Donation of Pepin founds the Papal States → Cadaver Synod tries Pope Formosus → Roman nobles dominate the papacy (saeculum obscurum) → Synod of Sutri deposes rival popes → Papal election decree gives cardinals the vote → Gregory VII's Dictatus papae → Urban II preaches the crusade at Clermont → First Crusade → Saladin ends the Fatimid Caliphate → Saladin retakes Jerusalem → Fourth Crusade sacks Constantinople → Fall of Constantinople → Halley's Comet of 1456 and the pope

The story

In June 1456 a bright comet with a long tail crossed the sky over Europe. Only three years earlier, the Ottoman Turks had taken Constantinople, and in July 1456 a Christian force under John Hunyadi relieved the siege of Belgrade. Many Europeans saw the comet as a sign of divine wrath or as a warning about the Turkish threat. Pope Callixtus III, who was organizing a crusade, is reported to have ordered prayers and processions for protection, and some accounts add that bells were rung each day.

A famous legend says the pope excommunicated the comet, a story told in many popular books. Historians find no support for it in papal documents of the time, and it seems to have grown from later retellings of the prayers. The legend lasted because it makes a neat picture: authority of Church against a force of nature. The comet itself is now known to be Halley's, and the 1456 apparition is one of many that astronomers use to trace its orbit.

Why it mattered

Shows how fear after the fall of Constantinople shaped how Europeans read the sky.
Created a persistent legend about the Church and astronomy that is still repeated.
Added a datapoint for Halley's orbit, checked against Chinese and European records.

Sources

Contested history

Consensus: Pope Callixtus III is reported to have ordered prayers during the comet of 1456; the claim that he formally excommunicated it is a later legend.

The pope ordered prayers and processions against the comet and the Turkish threatDebated

Reports are consistent, but they come from later writers rather than from papal documents.

Read this view

More ISON Craziness: Tales of Popes, a Prophet and a Comet Universe Today

The pope formally excommunicated Halley's CometDebunked

No papal bull or contemporary record shows it; the story appears later and looks like an embellishment.

Read this view

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

BookSara Schechner Genuth

At a glance

When: June 1456
Where: Across Europe and Asia
Key people: Callixtus III (pope, organizer of a crusade)
John Hunyadi (Hungarian commander at Belgrade)

3years between the fall of Constantinople and this comet

202earlier events it rests on

0later events that depend on it

Couldn't have happened without

Earliest firm records of Halley's Comet240 BCE

MajorThe comet was a return of the same body recorded since antiquity, as later orbit calculations show.

Fall of Constantinople1453

MajorFear of Ottoman advance after 1453 shaped how Christian Europe read the comet.

Made possible

Nothing on this timeline builds on it directly yet.

More from Age of Discovery

Fall of Constantinople1453 Columbus reaches the Americas1492 Columbian Exchange1493 Double-entry bookkeeping1494 Vasco da Gama reaches India by sea1498 Protestant Reformation1517