Sign in
Industrial AgeGovernment & Law

Paris Commune

1871MajorContested

Paris workers hold the city for two months in 1871 until the army retakes it and kills thousands, giving socialists a lasting model and a martyrdom.

The story

On March 18, 1871, French government troops tried to seize the cannon of the Paris National Guard on Montmartre, and the crowd and soldiers fraternized and killed two generals. The government of Adolphe Thiers withdrew to Versailles, and on March 26 Parisians elected a council, the Commune, with about 90 members: radical republicans, socialists and followers of Proudhon and Blanqui. For the next two months it governed the city.

The causes lay in the siege of Paris in the Franco-Prussian War. Parisians had endured hunger and cold and felt betrayed when the national government, elected in a country eager for peace, agreed to an armistice, ended the moratorium on rents and debts, and appeared ready to restore the monarchy. The National Guard of workers and craftsmen had arms and refused to disarm. The Commune separated church and state, banned night work in bakeries, gave pensions to the widows of National Guards, handed abandoned workshops to cooperatives, and adopted the red flag. Women organized in clubs and the Union of Women, and the painter Gustave Courbet led an arts committee.

The Versailles army entered Paris on May 21, and the week of fighting up to May 28 is called the Bloody Week. Soldiers shot many captured Communards, thousands died in the fighting and executions, and the Commune's own forces killed about 100 hostages, including the Archbishop of Paris, Georges Darboy. Tens of thousands were arrested and several thousand were deported, many to New Caledonia. Karl Marx wrote The Civil War in France, praising the Commune as a workers' government, and Lenin later studied it as a model and a lesson, although historians note that its leaders had no single plan.

Why it mattered

  • The Commune became a founding story for socialists and communists, who studied its decrees and its defeat.
  • The brutal repression poisoned French politics for a generation and made the Third Republic wary of the left.
  • Marx's analysis of the Commune shaped Marxist theory of the state, as Lenin later used in The State and Revolution.
  • Workers' councils, from Paris in 1871 to the soviets of 1905, echoed its direct democratic forms.

Sources

  1. Commune of Paris Britannica
  2. How bloody was la semaine sanglante of 1871? A revision The Historical Journal (Robert Tombs)
  3. The Civil War in France Marxists Internet Archive (Karl Marx)
  4. So Comrades Come Rally Marxists Internet Archive (Ian Birchall)

Contested history

Consensus: The Paris Commune was a radical government that ruled the city for 72 days in 1871 and was crushed by the national army, with thousands killed. Its political meaning is still argued.

Several thousand Communards were killed in the Bloody WeekEstablished
Modern research counts roughly 6,000 to 10,000 dead, many executed after capture.
Read this view
Tens of thousands died, as some contemporary and later accounts sayMinority view
Figures of 20,000 or more come from partisan sources and are not supported by burial records.
Read this view
The Commune was a model of working-class socialist ruleDebated
Marx and Lenin saw it so, but most of its members were republicans and radicals, and its actual measures were mixed.
Read this view

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

BookRobert Tombs
The Paris Commune 1871 ↗
Editor's pick
VideoSearch on YouTube
Paris Commune 1871 explained ↗
Editor's pick
VideoSearch on YouTube
Bloody Week Paris Commune ↗
Editor's pick
VideoSearch on YouTube
Karl Marx Civil War in France Commune ↗
Editor's pick