The story
On December 13, 1294, Pope Celestine V resigned the papacy after about five months in office. He was Pietro da Morrone, an elderly hermit and the founder of a monastic order, who had been elected on July 5 to end a deadlock in which the cardinals had failed to choose a pope for more than two years after Nicholas IV's death in 1292. The cardinals picked a holy man in the hope he would rise above their quarrels. But Celestine, who was about eighty, found the work of government and the pressure of politicians, above all of King Charles II of Naples, beyond him. He first issued a decree declaring that a pope could lawfully resign, and then did so.
The deadlock had been made worse by the absence of strict rules for papal elections, which Gregory X's 1274 decree Ubi periculum had set out and which was suspended for a time. Celestine reinstated the rules before he left. His resignation was almost unprecedented. His successor, Boniface VIII, elected on December 24, kept Celestine in confinement, in the castle of Fumone, where he died in 1296. Celestine was canonized in 1313. Dante placed a figure who made 'the great refusal' in the vestibule of Hell, and many commentators believed it was Celestine.
Why it mattered
- His decree and resignation set the precedent for later papal resignations, such as Gregory XII in 1415 and Benedict XVI in 2013.
- Boniface VIII, his successor, proclaimed the first Jubilee Year in 1300, which drew crowds of pilgrims to Rome.
- The episode showed the vulnerability of the papacy to political pressure, especially from the kings of France and Naples.
- Boniface's conflict with Philip IV of France, which followed, helped lead to the papacy's move to Avignon.
Sources
- St. Celestine V Britannica
- Pope's trip to L'Aquila raises questions about papal resignations National Catholic Reporter
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…