Sign in

Council of Pisa elects a third pope

1409

Cardinals from both obediences meet at Pisa, depose the Roman and Avignon popes and elect Alexander V. Neither rival steps down, so Europe has three claimants until Constance ends the schism.

The story

In March 1409, cardinals who had abandoned both rival popes gathered at Pisa in Italy for a council meant to end the Western Schism. Since 1378, the Church had been split between a pope in Rome and another in Avignon, each with his own cardinals and supporters among Europe's kings. Neither would resign. The council, attended by hundreds of clergy and representatives of many rulers, declared on 5 June that both Gregory XII of Rome and Benedict XIII of Avignon were schismatics and heretics and removed them. On 26 June the cardinals elected a new pope, Alexander V, who was a Franciscan scholar from Crete.

The plan failed in practice. Gregory and Benedict rejected the council's authority and kept their own followers, so Christendom now had three claimants. Alexander died in 1410 and was succeeded by John XXIII, chosen by the same group. Pressure for a more complete solution led the Holy Roman Emperor Sigismund to push for another council at Constance in 1414. Pisa had still advanced the idea of conciliarism, the claim that a general council holds authority over a pope, which Constance then used to end the schism by deposing John, accepting Gregory's resignation, removing Benedict and electing Martin V in 1417.

Why it mattered

  • The council of Constance (1414 to 1418) drew on Pisa's precedent to end the schism in 1417.
  • Conciliarism, the idea that councils can judge popes, gained force as a theory of church government.
  • The failed attempt showed that ending a division in the Church would require the backing of secular rulers.

Sources

  1. Council of Pisa Britannica
  2. Pope Gregory XII Catholic Encyclopedia

Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

Documentbritannica.com
Council of Pisa (Britannica)
Editor's pick
BookEamon Duffy
Saints and Sinners: A History of the Popes
Search Open Library
VideoSearch YouTube
Council of Pisa 1409 three popes
Search YouTube
VideoSearch YouTube
Western Schism explained history
Search YouTube