Sign in

Dagobert I's reported convert-or-leave order

c. 629 CE

The Chronicle of Fredegar says the Frankish king Dagobert I had Jews baptized, and a later source adds that refusers were expelled. Historians doubt how far, if at all, it was carried out.

The story

The Chronicle of Fredegar, written in Frankish Gaul around the 660s, reports that in 629 the Byzantine emperor Heraclius, warned by astrologers that circumcised peoples would ravage his empire, wrote to the Frankish king Dagobert I to have the Jews in his kingdom baptized. According to the chronicle, Dagobert ordered the Jews to be baptized in all his lands. A later text, the Gesta Dagoberti, written long afterward, adds that those who refused were expelled.

The story fits a wider setting. After the Visigothic kingdom's decrees and Heraclius's own order for forced baptisms in the Byzantine Empire, rulers saw religious unity as a source of strength. Dagobert I, who became ruler of the whole Frankish realm in 629, was a Catholic king backed by bishops and had recently taken power. But the evidence is thin. No contemporary law of Dagobert survives, the only source is the chronicler, who may have misunderstood events, and the expulsion appears only in sources written long after. Many historians doubt that a general order was ever carried out, or think that it was limited. For this reason the event is best described as a reported order whose reach is unknown.

Why it mattered

  • The report is cited in the long history of forced conversions and expulsions of Jews in medieval Europe, even though its reach is doubtful.
  • It shows how a rumor of religious policy could spread between Byzantium and the Frankish court.
  • It shows how historians weigh a single chronicle against the absence of laws or other evidence.

Sources

  1. Dagobert Jewish Encyclopedia
  2. Dagobert I Britannica

Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

Documentjewishencyclopedia.com
France (Jewish Encyclopedia, 1906)
Editor's pick
BookBernard S. Bachrach
Early Medieval Jewish Policy in Western Europe
Search Open Library
VideoSearch YouTube
Jews in Merovingian Gaul history
Search YouTube
VideoSearch YouTube
Dagobert I Frankish king
Search YouTube