The story
Marcion of Sinope, a wealthy shipowner from the Black Sea coast, came to Rome and around 144 CE was expelled from the church there. Tradition adds that the church returned his large donation. He had taught that the harsh God of the Hebrew Bible, the creator and giver of law, was a different and lesser being than the loving Father revealed by Jesus. To support this view he drew up his own scripture: one Gospel, a shortened form of Luke, and ten letters of Paul, with all references to the Jewish scriptures cut out. He also wrote a work called the Antitheses, setting passages of the two Testaments against each other.
Marcion's church spread widely in the empire and lasted for centuries. His rivals responded by affirming the Hebrew scriptures as Christian scripture, and by defending the four Gospels and a wider set of apostolic writings. His proposal is often called the first Christian canon, though some scholars note that collections of Paul's letters and the Gospels already existed. His own writings are lost, and he is known mostly through his opponents, especially Tertullian's long book Against Marcion. A Christian canon of 27 books would take until Athanasius in 367 to be listed, but the process was spurred by Marcion's challenge.
Why it mattered
- His challenge pushed the church to decide which books counted as scripture.
- The church defended the Old Testament as Christian scripture against his rejection of it.
- Athanasius's 367 list of the 27-book New Testament grew from debates he provoked.
Sources
- Marcion of Pontus Britannica
- Biblical canon Britannica
- Marcionites Catholic Encyclopedia
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…