Sign in

Regulation NMS and high-frequency trading

2007

New SEC rules fragment U.S. trading across many electronic venues, and high-frequency trading firms grow to handle much of the volume.

The story

Regulation NMS, adopted by the US Securities and Exchange Commission in 2005 and phased in through 2007, was a set of rules meant to make US stock markets more competitive and fair. Its central part, the Order Protection Rule, required that a trade be executed at the best displayed price across all trading venues, so that a broker could not fill an order at a worse price on one exchange when a better one was available on another. Other rules limited quoting in fractions of a cent and set how market data is shared.

The aim was to protect investors, but the effect was to split trading. Before, the New York Stock Exchange handled most trading in its listed shares. Under the new rules, orders were routed among many electronic exchanges and private venues called dark pools, which each tried to win business through speed and fees. Computers, not human specialists, now matched trades. High-frequency trading firms, which use fast algorithms and direct connections to exchanges to buy and sell thousands of times a second, thrived on this fragmented market, serving as market makers. By around 2009 estimates put them at more than half of US share volume. Spreads narrowed for ordinary investors, but critics argued the system was complex and vulnerable, as shown in the Flash Crash of 2010.

Why it mattered

  • Competition among exchanges lowered trading costs for most investors.
  • High-frequency trading grew into a major force and was central to market structure debates.
  • The 2010 Flash Crash exposed how fast the new market could break down.
  • Michael Lewis's 2014 book Flash Boys and the founding of the exchange IEX brought public attention to speed advantages.

Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

BookMichael Lewis
Flash Boys
Search Open Library
VideoSearch YouTube
high frequency trading explained
Search YouTube