The story
In 833, shortly before his death, the Abbasid caliph al-Ma'mun ordered his governors to examine judges and scholars on a single question: was the Quran created, or was it the uncreated word of God? The caliph backed the first view, which came from the Mu'tazila, a school of rational theology. The test, called the Mihna ('trial' or inquisition), was meant to confirm the caliph's own role as a guide in matters of faith. Those who refused could be dismissed from office or punished. Ma'mun's successors, al-Mu'tasim and al-Wathiq, continued it.
Most scholars gave in. Ahmad ibn Hanbal, a jurist and hadith scholar in Baghdad, refused. He was imprisoned and flogged, and his steadfastness made him a hero to the public. When the caliph al-Mutawakkil ended the policy between 849 and 851, the ulama (religious scholars) emerged stronger, and the caliph's claim to define doctrine was weakened. The ulama came to be seen as the guardians of Islam, independent of rulers, and the school of Ahmad ibn Hanbal, the Hanbali school, was named after him. The Mu'tazila lost official support and, over time, much of their influence in Sunni Islam.
Why it mattered
- Religious scholars won lasting independence from the state, so that authority to define belief in Sunni Islam rested with the ulama.
- The caliphs lost the claim to settle questions of doctrine, a shift that left them chiefly political rulers.
- The Hanbali school, rooted in textual literalism, grew from Ahmad ibn Hanbal's example.
- Rationalist theology lost ground in Sunni Islam, as traditionist scholars gained influence.
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…