The story
Between 1734 and 1738, Prospero Lambertini, the archbishop of Bologna, published a multi-volume Latin treatise called De servorum Dei beatificatione et beatorum canonizatione (On the Beatification of the Servants of God and the Canonization of the Blessed). Lambertini became Pope Benedict XIV in 1740. The work laid out, in great legal detail, how the Catholic Church should investigate whether a deceased person should be declared blessed or a saint. It stayed the standard guide for more than two centuries.
Lambertini wrote from experience. Earlier in his career he had served as Promoter of the Faith, the official nicknamed the devil's advocate, whose job was to argue against a candidate for sainthood and find holes in the evidence. The procedures he described grew from the decrees of Pope Urban VIII in the 1620s and 1630s, which required proof of heroic virtue and, in most cases, of miracles worked after death. In an age of growing scientific scepticism, the Church wanted its process to hold up to scrutiny.
Lambertini's most influential contribution was a set of tests for claimed miraculous cures. In the Church's own procedure, the illness had to be grave and not about to end by itself, the recovery had to be sudden rather than gradual, complete rather than partial, and lasting rather than temporary. Medicine had to have failed or played no part. Physicians were to be consulted as experts. This is what the Church's teaching process asks about a claim, and it does not argue that science can prove or disprove a miracle. Later reforms, above all in 1983 under John Paul II, simplified the process and abolished the devil's advocate, but the central questions about cures have been kept, and in the twentieth century they were put to a permanent panel of physicians that advises the Vatican.
Why it mattered
- Miracle claims came to be examined by medical experts, a practice that grew into the Vatican's standing medical board for judging cures.
- The sainthood process gained a written rulebook, which gave later popes a stable legal framework to revise rather than invent.
- Lambertini's demand for rigour reflected Enlightenment-era scepticism within the Church itself, as it adapted to a more critical age.
- The 'devil's advocate' office he had held, and described, became a lasting phrase in everyday English for anyone who argues the other side.
Sources
- Revising the supernatural: Prospero Lambertini's reconsideration of the concept of miracle Church History (Cambridge University Press)
- Five facts about canonization Oxford University Press
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…