The story
The 'devil's advocate' is the popular name for the promoter of the faith (promotor fidei), an official of the Catholic Church whose job in a sainthood case was to question the evidence. When someone was proposed for sainthood, he examined the life, writings and alleged miracles of the candidate and raised every reasonable objection, so that the case for sanctity would be tested before the pope ruled. The office was formalized in the church reforms of Pope Sixtus V in the late 1580s, when he reorganized the papal government and set up a Congregation of Rites to handle such cases.
Behind the office lay a worry that grew through the Reformation. Protestant critics attacked the cult of saints as superstition, and the Council of Trent had ordered reform. The pope had reserved canonization to himself since the Middle Ages, and a rigorous trial protected the process from fraud, such as false relics and invented miracles. The process was refined by later popes. Prospero Lambertini, who served as promoter of the faith in the early 1700s and became Pope Benedict XIV, wrote the standard work on beatification in the 1730s and 1740s. In 1983 John Paul II abolished the adversarial role, replacing it with a promoter of justice and reducing the number of required miracles.
Why it mattered
- Sainthood cases gained a rigorous, quasi-legal procedure with evidence, witnesses and formal objections.
- Benedict XIV's rules on miracles and heroic virtue shaped canonization for centuries.
- The phrase 'devil's advocate' passed into everyday English for anyone who argues the opposing side to test an idea.
- John Paul II's 1983 reform changed the process and led to far more canonizations.
Sources
- Devil's advocate Britannica
- Christopher Hitchens (Commonweal) Commonweal
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…