The story
On September 5, 1234, Pope Gregory IX issued a new collection of church law, known as the Decretals, or the Liber Extra, which was compiled by the Dominican lawyer Raymond of Penyafort. It had five books and replaced earlier collections, and it became the standard text of Catholic canon law for nearly seven centuries. Among its entries was a ruling of Pope Alexander III, from a case called Audivimus, which said that no one may be venerated as a saint without the approval of the Roman Church, even when miracles are reported. In effect, this made canonization the pope's decision.
For the first thousand years of Christianity, saints were made by local acclaim: a martyr or holy bishop was honored by a community, and the local bishop often approved it. The first papal canonization on record is that of Ulrich of Augsburg in 993, and Alexander III had canonized Thomas Becket in 1173. Alexander's ruling in Audivimus came in a case about a man killed while drunk, whom some had begun to honor as a saint. The pope declared that veneration should not begin without Rome's authority. By 1234, with the papal courts growing in prestige, Gregory had the principle written into the church's law book.
Over time, a legal procedure took shape. Investigators gathered evidence of holy life and miracles through witnesses and documents, and the process came to include a formal advocate whose job was to challenge the case, popularly called the devil's advocate. The Congregation of Rites, created in 1588, took over the task in Rome. Thomas Aquinas was canonized under this system in 1323. The Liber Extra remained in force until the first Code of Canon Law of 1917.
Why it mattered
- Saints became a papal matter, supervised by formal trials and legal rules rather than local custom.
- Canonization processes developed a standard of proof, including the office of the devil's advocate.
- The Congregation of Rites, created in 1588, turned the process into a permanent department of the Roman Curia.
- The Liber Extra shaped Church law until the first Code of Canon Law in 1917.
Sources
- Canonization Britannica
- Gregory IX and the Liber Extra Cambridge University Press
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…