The story
On March 6, 1857, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Dred Scott v. Sandford that Dred Scott, an enslaved man, was not free and could not sue in federal court. The seven-to-two decision, written by Chief Justice Roger Taney, went far beyond the case. It held that Black people, whether enslaved or free, were not and could never be citizens of the United States, and that Congress had no power to bar slavery in the territories, which made the Missouri Compromise unconstitutional.
Scott had been taken by his owner, an army surgeon named John Emerson, from Missouri, a slave state, to Illinois and to the Wisconsin Territory, where slavery was illegal. After Emerson's death Scott sued for freedom in a St. Louis court in 1846 on the ground that residence on free soil had made him free, a claim earlier Missouri courts had accepted. He lost a first trial on a technicality, won a retrial in 1850, lost before the Missouri Supreme Court in 1852 and then lost in federal court. The Supreme Court heard the case just after the Kansas-Nebraska Act had reopened the fight over slavery in the territories.
The ruling did the opposite. Northerners were angered by the claim that slavery could not be barred anywhere in the territories, and by the statement that Black Americans had no rights. The Republican Party, formed to stop the spread of slavery, gained support, and Abraham Lincoln attacked the decision in his 1858 debates with Stephen Douglas. Scott's owners, the family of his first master, freed him in May 1857, and he died of tuberculosis in 1858. The decision was later reversed by the Thirteenth Amendment, which ended slavery, and the Fourteenth, which in 1868 declared that anyone born in the United States is a citizen. It is often named as one of the worst decisions in the Court's history.
Why it mattered
- Sectional tension rose sharply, as Northerners saw the decision as proof of a plot to spread slavery nationwide.
- The Republican Party gained strength, and Lincoln's rise helped him win the 1860 election.
- The Fourteenth Amendment's citizenship clause was written in part to overturn it.
- It damaged the public standing of the Supreme Court for a generation.
Sources
- Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857) National Archives
- Scott v. Sandford EBSCO Research Starters
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…