Sign in

First bond ratings

1909

John Moody publishes letter grades for railroad bonds in his Analyses of Railroad Investments. Credit ratings become a gatekeeper of bond markets.

The story

In 1909 the American financial analyst John Moody published Moody's Analyses of Railroad Investments, which rated the quality of railroad bonds using letter grades. The scale ran from Aaa for the safest bonds down through lower grades, so that an investor could see at a glance how likely a borrower was to pay back its debt. Moody sold his analyses by subscription to investors. It was the first widely used system of credit ratings for bonds.

By 1909 the New York Stock Exchange and a growing national railroad network, including the transcontinental railroad, had created a large market in bonds that ordinary investors could buy but could not easily judge. Moody had published a manual of corporate securities since 1900 and had to start over after the Panic of 1907 wrecked his firm. His ratings were a simple, public summary of the quality of a debt. Competitors followed, with Poor's in 1916, Standard Statistics in 1922 and Fitch in 1924, and by the 1920s Moody's rated nearly all the bonds in the U.S. market. In the 1930s regulators began using the ratings to decide which bonds banks could hold, which gave the grades the force of rules and separated 'investment grade' from speculative bonds.

Why it mattered

  • Bond markets gained a shared language of credit risk that let issuers reach many investors.
  • Regulators wrote ratings into rules, giving a few firms great influence over who could borrow cheaply.
  • The split between investment grade and speculative grade led to the high-yield bond market, which grew in the 1980s.
  • Failures of the agencies, notably their top grades for risky mortgage securities before 2008, brought heavy criticism.

Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

BookMichael Lewis
The Big Short
Search Open Library
VideoSearch YouTube
history of credit rating agencies
Search YouTube