The story
In May 1747, aboard the Royal Navy ship HMS Salisbury, the ship's surgeon James Lind chose twelve sailors suffering from scurvy and tested treatments on them. He picked men whose cases looked as alike as he could manage, kept them in the same part of the ship, and fed them the same basic diet. Then he split them into six pairs and gave each pair a different remedy: cider, a dilute sulphuric acid, vinegar, seawater, two oranges and a lemon a day, or a paste of garlic and other seasonings. The pair given citrus fruit recovered fastest. One sailor was fit for duty within about six days, and the other became nurse to the rest of the sick.
Scurvy was one of the great killers of the age of sail. It starts with weakness, bleeding gums and old wounds that reopen, and can end in death. George Anson's voyage around the world (1740 to 1744) lost well over half of its crews, most of them to scurvy. Physicians offered many theories and cures, and arguments rested on opinion and tradition. Lind's experiment broke with that habit. By comparing treatments among similar patients at the same time, he followed the reasoning that Francis Bacon had recommended for finding causes. Today we know scurvy comes from lack of vitamin C, which the body cannot make and which fresh fruit supplies.
Lind published A Treatise of the Scurvy in 1753, but he did not push the result hard. He also recommended boiled lemon juice concentrate, which loses vitamin C when heated, and the evidence seemed muddled. It took decades for the Navy to act. Around 1795 the Royal Navy began issuing lemon juice to sailors, and scurvy at sea quickly dwindled. The trial's larger legacy was a method: group similar patients, compare treatments, and judge by outcome, which later grew into the controlled clinical trial.
Why it mattered
- The Royal Navy's lemon juice ration, introduced in the 1790s, kept crews healthy on long voyages and helped Britain's naval power.
- The discovery of vitamins in the twentieth century explained why citrus worked, and showed that diseases can come from missing nutrients.
- Comparing treatments among similar patients became a pattern for testing medicine, reaching a high point in the streptomycin trial of 1946 to 1948.
- Long ocean voyages and exploration became safer, since crews no longer lost a large share of men to scurvy.
Sources
- A treatise of the scurvy (Lind 1753) James Lind Library
- James Lind Britannica
- James Lind Linda Hall Library
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…