The story
In October 1948 the British Medical Journal published the results of a trial of the antibiotic streptomycin against pulmonary tuberculosis, run by the Medical Research Council (MRC). Of 107 patients with severe, recent tuberculosis in both lungs, 55 were given streptomycin plus bed rest and 52 bed rest alone, and the choice for each patient was made by random numbers. After six months, 28 of the streptomycin patients had improved considerably, compared with 4 of the controls, and 4 of the 55 had died, compared with 14 of the 52. The study is often called the first modern randomized controlled trial.
Streptomycin had been discovered in 1943 by Selman Waksman's laboratory in the United States, with his student Albert Schatz, and it was the first drug to attack tuberculosis effectively. Supplies in Britain were scarce, which made it ethically defensible to treat only some patients. The trial was designed by the statistician Austin Bradford Hill, who knew the history of earlier controlled comparisons, such as James Lind's shipboard test of scurvy treatments in 1747. Hill's key step was to make sure that doctors could not choose who got the drug, since a doctor who believes in a treatment may unconsciously give it to healthier patients. Allocation was by sealed envelopes opened only after a patient was enrolled, and the specialists who read the X-rays did not know which group a patient belonged to.
The results were clear, and so was a warning: in many patients the bacteria became resistant to streptomycin within months, which led to combination treatment with other drugs and, eventually, to cures. The method spread, and by the 1960s it had become the standard way to test drugs. After the thalidomide tragedy, the United States passed the Kefauver-Harris amendments of 1962, requiring drug makers to prove effectiveness in well-controlled studies. Randomization is now the foundation of evidence-based medicine.
Why it mattered
- The Kefauver-Harris Amendments of 1962 required controlled trials as proof that a drug works before it can be sold in the United States.
- Randomized trials became the standard way to separate real treatments from fashions, from heart drugs to vaccines.
- Combination treatment of tuberculosis arose from the resistance the trial revealed, and led to cures.
- Evidence-based medicine, the idea that treatments should be judged by trial results, became a guiding principle of modern health care.
Sources
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…