The story
In 1910 the educator Abraham Flexner published Medical Education in the United States and Canada, a report for the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching. Flexner had visited all 155 medical schools in the two countries in 1909 and 1910, and his verdict was harsh. Many schools had no laboratories, no hospital for teaching and little entrance standard, and they were run as businesses by their owners, who took fees from students. The report called for medicine to be taught as a science, and within a generation it had remade medical education.
In the 1800s anyone could set up a medical school, and training could last as little as two years of lectures. Meanwhile, the medical sciences of bacteriology and physiology had matured, and Europe, especially Germany, trained doctors in research universities. The Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, which opened in 1893, was the American model, requiring a college degree, two years of basic science followed by two years in a teaching hospital, and full-time faculty doing research. Flexner, who was not a doctor himself, held up Hopkins as the standard.
The report's effect was strong because state licensing boards and philanthropies, notably the Rockefeller-funded General Education Board, followed its lead. Weak schools lost accreditation and funding: the number fell from 155 in 1910 to about 66 by 1935. Training became more uniform and scientific, with university affiliation, laboratory teaching and clinical clerkships, which improved the quality of doctors. But the reform also had costs. Most of the Black medical schools were closed, leaving only Howard and Meharry, and the women's medical colleges nearly vanished, and rural and low-income areas lost small-town doctors and cheaper training routes. Flexner's approach has been criticized for favoring a narrow biomedical view and for its views on race.
Why it mattered
- Medical schools became part of universities, with a standard sequence of basic science and clinical training that is still the model.
- Licensing and accreditation were tightened, closing weaker schools and raising the standard of practice.
- The sharp fall in Black and women physicians' training paths reduced access to the profession for decades, which is still studied today.
- The cost and length of training grew, which shaped the economics and supply of doctors.
Sources
- Abraham Flexner Britannica
- The Flexner Report (1900-1926, Section 4) University of Houston Center for Public History (archived copy)
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…