The story
In May 1493, Pope Alexander VI issued a set of bulls (formal papal letters) answering Spain's request after Columbus returned from his first voyage. The best known, Inter caetera, granted Spain the lands and islands that it found west of a line running 100 leagues west of the Azores and the Cape Verde Islands, so long as no other Christian ruler already held them. In exchange, Spain was to see to the conversion of the peoples there to Christianity.
Behind the grant lay a dispute with Portugal. Earlier popes had given Portugal rights in Africa, notably Romanus Pontifex in 1455, and the 1479 Treaty of Alcacovas had reserved the southern Atlantic to Portugal. When Columbus came back in March 1493 from lands in the west, King John II of Portugal claimed them. Ferdinand and Isabella turned to the pope, who was Rodrigo Borgia, born near Valencia, and they got the answer they wanted. The bulls rested on the medieval idea that the pope could assign non-Christian lands to Christian rulers for missionary work, a principle later called the doctrine of discovery.
Nothing about the line suited Portugal. It left the sea route around Africa uncertain, and John II threatened to send a fleet. The two crowns negotiated directly and, by the Treaty of Tordesillas in June 1494, moved the line far to the west. Meanwhile the idea that a pope could hand out the world, and that Christian discovery outweighed the rights of those already living there, became part of European legal thinking about empire. Other powers, including France, England and the Dutch, rejected the papal division, but they used similar arguments of discovery and possession in their own claims.
Why it mattered
- The Treaty of Tordesillas followed within a year, as Portugal bargained the line westward.
- A mission-focused papal empire took shape, leading to bodies such as the Propaganda Fide, founded by Gregory XV in 1622.
- The doctrine of discovery entered European law and was later cited in United States court rulings, including Johnson v. M'Intosh in 1823.
- Spanish rule in the Americas gained a religious justification that shaped debates over the treatment of Indigenous peoples.
Sources
- Inter caetera, 1493 Papal Encyclicals Online
- Treaty of Tordesillas Britannica
- Doctrine of Discovery World History Encyclopedia
- Alexander VI Britannica
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…