The story
On January 8, 1455, Pope Nicholas V issued the papal bull Romanus Pontifex, addressed to King Afonso V of Portugal. It praised the Portuguese for their voyages along the African coast and granted them exclusive rights to the lands and seas they had found and would find, from Cape Bojador and Cape Nao southward toward the Indies. It also gave the Portuguese permission to attack, capture and enslave non-Christian peoples and to take their lands and goods.
The bull followed Dum diversas of 1452, which had already given Afonso V the authority to conquer and enslave Muslims and pagans. Behind them lay Portugal's expansion after the capture of Ceuta in 1415. Prince Henry and the Crown wanted to secure their gains against Castile and other rivals, and the papacy, which thought of itself as the arbiter among Christian rulers, could give such a monopoly legal weight. For the pope, the voyages also promised a way to spread the faith and, he hoped, to find Christian allies against the Ottomans, who had taken Constantinople in 1453.
The consequences were grave. The bull gave religious approval to the Atlantic slave trade, which the Portuguese were already carrying out, and helped to justify taking land from non-Christian peoples. Its argument was repeated in later documents. In 1493 Alexander VI's Inter caetera divided the Atlantic world between Spain and Portugal, and it was followed by the Treaty of Tordesillas in 1494. Together these texts are the foundation of what is now called the doctrine of discovery, which European powers and later the United States used to claim sovereignty over Indigenous lands. In March 2023 the Vatican formally repudiated the doctrine.
Why it mattered
- Inter caetera in 1493 extended the model of papal grants to the lands Columbus found, dividing the Atlantic between Spain and Portugal.
- The doctrine of discovery drawn from these bulls was used for centuries to justify taking Indigenous lands, including in United States law.
- Papal approval for enslaving non-Christians gave moral cover to the growth of the Atlantic slave trade.
- The Vatican's formal repudiation of the doctrine in 2023 shows how long the legal and moral legacy lasted.
Sources
- Romanus Pontifex, 1455 Papal Encyclicals Online
- Vatican formally rejects doctrine of discovery after Indigenous calls PBS NewsHour
- Classic Cases in Property: Johnson v. M'Intosh University of Minnesota Law Library
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…