The story
On February 24, 1803, the United States Supreme Court, in an opinion written by Chief Justice John Marshall, held that part of a federal law was unconstitutional and therefore void. The case, Marbury v. Madison, is the foundation of judicial review in the United States, the power of courts to strike down laws that conflict with the Constitution. The Constitution never states this power outright, and Marshall's reasoning is the reason it exists in practice.
The dispute began as a political fight. Before leaving office in March 1801, President John Adams and the outgoing Federalist Congress created new judgeships and filled them with allies, the so-called midnight appointments. William Marbury was named a justice of the peace for the District of Columbia, but his commission was not delivered before Thomas Jefferson took office. Jefferson told his Secretary of State, James Madison, to withhold it. Marbury sued, asking the Supreme Court to order delivery under a section of the Judiciary Act of 1789.
Marshall found himself in a trap, since the Republican administration would probably ignore any order to deliver the commission. His answer was a masterstroke. He wrote that Marbury had a right to the commission and that the law provided a remedy, but that the Court could not give it, because the section of the 1789 act allowing such cases to start in the Supreme Court went beyond what Article III of the Constitution allowed. He reasoned that the Constitution is supreme law, that a law contradicting it is not law, and that it is 'emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is.' The Court gave up a small power, and Jefferson's side won the case, but the judges gained a much larger one. The Court did not strike down another federal law until 1857, but the principle stuck.
Why it mattered
- Judicial review became the basis for courts to check Congress and the president, shaping American constitutional politics ever since.
- The Supreme Court became a co-equal branch with the power to interpret the Constitution, not merely to settle private disputes.
- The principle was applied dramatically in Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857) and in many later rulings on civil rights, speech and executive power.
- Other countries, including India, Germany and Japan, adopted constitutional courts with similar powers in the twentieth century.
Sources
- Marbury v. Madison (1803) National Archives
- Marbury v. Madison Britannica
- Marbury v. Madison World History Encyclopedia
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…