The story
In April 1059, at a council in the Lateran Palace in Rome, Pope Nicholas II issued a decree known as In nomine Domini that changed who chooses the pope. It gave the main role to the cardinal bishops, the seven senior clergy of the dioceses around Rome. They were to meet first and name a candidate. The other cardinals would then join them, and the rest of the Roman clergy and people would give their assent. The decree also said the candidate should preferably come from the Roman church and left the young German king, Henry IV, only a vague right of honor and reverence.
The rule responded to a long crisis. For centuries the papacy had been controlled by the Roman noble families, who treated it as a prize. In 1046 the emperor Henry III used the Synod of Sutri to remove three rival claimants and install a German bishop, Clement II, so emperors then picked popes for a time. When Henry III died and a child king followed, the Roman nobles struck back: after Stephen IX died in March 1058 they elected their own man, Benedict X. Reformers led by the cleric Hildebrand, the future Gregory VII, backed a different candidate who became Nicholas II, and they needed a legal claim to show his election was valid and Benedict's was not.
The decree was an act of reform and of power. By reserving the choice to a small body of senior churchmen, the reformers shut out both the Roman nobles and the emperor. The text survives in two versions, a papal one and an imperial one that gives the German ruler more say, and the difference was itself a sign of the coming conflict. Gregory VII pressed these claims much further in his Dictatus papae of 1075, and the Third Lateran Council in 1179 added the requirement of a two-thirds majority.
Why it mattered
- The College of Cardinals took shape as the body that elects popes, a system that remains in place today.
- Emperors lost their control over papal elections, setting the stage for the Investiture Controversy of the 1070s.
- Popes gained the independence to claim authority over kings, as Gregory VII did in the Dictatus papae.
- The Third Lateran Council's two-thirds rule in 1179 refined the procedure, and later rules for the conclave developed from it.
Sources
- Conclave Britannica
- Nicholas II Britannica
- Papal Elections Catholic Encyclopedia
- Pope Nicholas II Catholic Encyclopedia
Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made
Community notes
Loading notes…