Sign in

Synod of Sutri deposes rival popes

1046

Emperor Henry III holds a synod that removes three rival claimants and installs a German pope. A run of reforming popes follows, beginning the Gregorian reform.

The story

In December 1046, the German king Henry III crossed the Alps into Italy to deal with a crisis in the papacy. Three men claimed to be pope: Benedict IX, who had been pope twice and had been driven out and returned; Sylvester III, put in during his absence; and Gregory VI, who had paid Benedict to resign. At the Synod of Sutri, near Rome, on December 20, Gregory VI was persuaded or forced to step down, and Sylvester was condemned, and Benedict was deposed at Rome days later. Henry then had his own candidate, the German bishop Suidger of Bamberg, chosen as Pope Clement II, and on Christmas Day Clement crowned him emperor.

For a century, powerful Roman families such as the Crescentii and the Tusculani had treated the papacy as a prize, and in that time the office suffered. The Holy Roman Empire's rulers, who saw themselves as protectors of the church, now used their power to cleanse it. Henry installed a series of reform-minded German popes, of whom the most important was Leo IX, chosen in 1049, and they attacked simony (the buying of church offices). The paradox of Sutri is that an emperor's power made the reform possible, and the reformed papacy, in time, would claim authority over emperors.

Why it mattered

  • The reform papacy that began here led to the Gregorian reform, which attacked simony and lay control of the church.
  • The papal election decree of 1059 gave the cardinals the leading role in choosing popes to end outside interference.
  • The reformers' claims of papal supremacy led to the Investiture Controversy with the Empire, and to Canossa in 1077.

Sources

  1. Synod of Sutri Britannica
  2. Benedict IX Britannica

Drafted by AI (Claude) from the sources above and checked against them by AI; no historian has reviewed this page. Spot a mistake? Suggest a correction. How pages are made

Community notes

Loading notes…

Learn more ranked by votes

Documentbritannica.com
Synod of Sutri (Britannica)
Editor's pick
Documentnewadvent.org
Pope Clement II (Catholic Encyclopedia, New Advent)
Editor's pick
BookEamon Duffy
Saints and Sinners: A History of the Popes
Search Open Library
VideoSearch YouTube
Synod of Sutri 1046
Search YouTube
VideoSearch YouTube
Henry III and the papal reform
Search YouTube